[Joel Chesser]

Looks as thought they are yet again remaking The Three Musketeers.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1509767/

Looks like a pretty good cast, let's hope it comes out as good if not better a movie.

[Joel Chesser]

Hmm...just looked at the directors previous works, hoping for a good movie may not be enough.

[Walter S]

I suspect that the movie will have hardly anything common with the source material, except the name. Paul Anderson has habit of turning source material on its head... Particularly by ham-fistedly cramming Milla where she isn't supposed to be... Who has seen Resident Evil movies know what I mean.

[Neil Langley]

[Walter S]

Actually, I like Milla too and even kinda liked Resident Evil movies, particularly the second one, Apocalypse. However that doesn't change that Alice is a character for which is no basis in the games, which is what I meant by turning source material on its head and cramming Milla in. It could have feel a lot closer to the games if the movies were written with Jill Valentine as main character played by Milla.

[Anders Backlund]

Well, there's already been like a million Three Musketeers movies, I suppose one more won't hurt. I wouldn't even call it a remake, honestly.

[Lucas Simms]

[Gottfried P. Doerler]

I best like the 1993 version of the three musketeers.
i doubt there could be a better cardinal than tim curry.

[Marko Susimetsa]

The 1970's version is the best of them all. I had high hopes for the 90's version, but the movie made some bad mistakes with character motivations etc. that really bothered me (ref. Athos' relationship with and feelings towards Milady De Winter).

Don't really hope for much from this latest version. It will be difficult to surpass the 1970's version in any case.

[Jean Thibodeau]

Then there is the 1948 version with Gene Kelly:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Musketeers_(1948_film)

[Craig Johnson]

Did not hear about this till I saw the post this morning. Not sure how I missed it.

As to previous renditions some are part of the small group of movies that are the best sword flicks ever made. SOme much less so

I would advise keeping ones expectations low for such an effort. Gives one the best shot at going to see it and being pleasantly surprised. Which would be a great thing

Did a quick search and here are some pics. Does not look like they really went over the top on the weapons and armor, to bad.

Love the story, think the 70's version is probably one of the best sword movies ever made and one should not talk about sword flicks until you have seen it









Larger Musketeers Pic

Hope it surprises us!

Craig

[Matthew Stagmer]

Milla Jovovich? All for one and one for zombies?

Always fun to watch another 3 Musketeers movie. Its all in the boots. Hope they went all out.

[Anders Backlund]

I liked the 1948 version. I also liked the 1993 version, even though the later had almost nothing to do with the novel. (Oliver Platt's portrayal of Porthos helped a lot.) I genuinely disliked the 1973 version, though.

Over-all, I think it's entirely subjective which is better then any other, and it will probably be the same thing with this one all over again.

[Martin Whalen]

I've said it before, but Hollywood is pathetic, utterly pathetic.

They're remake every single film at one time or another, and remake every classic story thousands of times over, like this one.

I'm just wondering how this is even relevant, but you can ask the same of the dozens of King Arthur films over the last two decades as well.

I won't even rent this, there are decent films about this subject already, move on Hollyweird, think for yourself for a change.

Hollyweird is why I only rent movies 15-40ish years old.

[Roger Hooper]

speaking of Musketeer swords, here are 2 aluminum prop swords from the 1990's Man in the Iron Mask.

John Malkovich's Athos sword and Jeremy Iron's Aramis sword.

And for best Musketeer movie, my vote goes fo the 1973 version, written by George Macdonald Fraser of Flashman fame.

[Ben P.]

[Patrick Kelly]

The costumes appear to be half-arsed and the weapons only a small step above. I'm sure my son and I will see it regardless. It features two of lifes guilty pleasures: swords and Milla Jovovich.

I don't have high hopes for it of course. Given the directors track record I expect it to be slightly better that a poke in the eye with a sharp stick. The 1973 version is by far my favorite. One cannot be a sword geek from my generation and not have been affected by Richard Lesters creation. It was one of the movies I'd run home to see after school as a child so regardless of its inherent inaccuracies I consider it the yardstick of severity for Three Musketeers movies. The Gene Kelly production is a great romp, but I'd rather vomit in my mouth than see the 90's era abomination again. We won't even discuss the gravity defying The Musketeer.

[Joel Chesser]

I saw The Musketeer and hated. I remember watching the 1993 movie when i was a kid so that one will always have a special place in my heart. I'd much prefer to see a director of higher quality at the helm of this. That said this director tends to do movies that are crappy, but fun, so I will go into it looking for little more than entertainment. As long as it succeeds there, I'll be happy.
I figure if this one is terrible I'll only have to wait another 15-20 years for them to take another stab at it.

[Sander Marechal]

I occasionally watch Man in the Iron Mask. The movie isn't that good, but Gerard Depardieu is just brilliant as Porthos.

[Mikko Kuusirati]