Thinking about getting my first sword... need some advice -- myArmoury.com

Harold R.

Although I have been hanging around here for a few weeks and I have been wishfully drooling over the idea of buying a sword for years now, I haven't really actually been planning to buy one until now. I would like to get into viking reenacting but I know that I have a whole lot of learning and research to do before I get anywhere near that. For now though I would like to get my hands on a sword that would work for that time period. The rest of the costume can wait.
I am thinking that I will most likely end up with at least two eventually - one "safe" sword that isn't sharpened for practice and reenacting and one SHARP one just to have around. Both will need to be durable enough to stand up to some use and the one for reenacting may need to take straight up abuse. It needs to be solid enough to trust but cheap enough that if I do destroy it I can replace it without too much pain.
To start with...
What about Paul Binns swords? Could I reasonably expect one of his swords to stand up to the beating that my practice / training / reenacting sword would see? The criteria for this one will be that from a distance it has at least a similar profile to a "real" sword, that it be tough, that it handle somewhat like a sharpened sword of this style, and that I just about have to intentionally smack myself with it to get hurt with it. I am a complete amateur with a sword. I am OK in a fistfight, tolerable with a handgun, and pretty good with a rifle but swordsmanship is an art that my dad didn't have to pass on to his sons. I want to get this one soon so I can get started teaching myself until I can get associated with a group to learn from.
The second one will need to be a functional sword that I would mostly just own and handle but that I could actually use in real combat should the need ever arise. I am thinking that the Albion Squire Viking may be a decent starter for this. It may end up getting traded or sold to go toward another sword later on so there isn't a huge need for me to buy the most expensive, highly finished sword I can find just yet. WIll the Squire viking sword work for this?
Thank you.

Jeremiah Swanger

Russ Ellis · Industry Professional

As a side note there is currently a Paul Binns blunt and seax blunt in the classifieds.

Chad Arnow · myArmoury Team

Bill Grandy · myArmoury Team

Hi Harold,
The Albion squire Viking you mentioned should be just fine for this. I haven't handled that model in particular, but have handled the other squire line swords, so I think you'll be quite happy with that one for a sword that's under $400. Keep in mind that it comes unsharpened (unless if you request it to be sharp).

As for the training blunt, you said it should be able to hold up to reenactment for when you get started. Here's my advice: Wait until you get started, and they'll tell you what kind you need. Different groups have different requirements: minimum blade thickness, different levels of acceptable authenticity, etc. You may get a blade that is perfect for one group, but not enough for another. Now, if you just want an unsharpened practice sword so that you won't cut yourself when swinging it around without a partner, the Albion squire line Viking will be quite fine for this.

Hope this helps!

Eric Allen · Posted: Fri 10 Feb, 2006 9:17 am Post subject:

I would also reccomend getting a waster for practicing.

Russ Ellis · Industry Professional

Harold R. · Posted: Fri 10 Feb, 2006 12:16 pm Post subject:

Thank you for the leads. I will keep checking back but I am going to be away for a few days. Keep 'em coming.

Shane Allee · Industry Professional

Just to echo what others have said. People seem to be very happy with their Binn's swords for re-enacting. It is always good to have an idea of what others in a group are using when picking your sword as well. Some swords will stand up very well with use when paired up against other similar swords, but when pitted against others they don't do as well. So it is always good to avoid getting something that might not hold up to use of others swords, or be something that might cause undo wear on fellow group members swords.

I did check Paul's website out just the other day and it looked as if he had a tri lobed sword available for sale right now.

Shane

Ryan Moody · Posted: Sat 11 Feb, 2006 5:32 pm Post subject:

Hey Harold, I'm a new sword collector myself (In fact, this is my first post on this forum at all), and I've just recieved my Albion Squire Line Viking sword a few days ago. It's amazing. Truly beautiful, and a bargain as far as I'm concerned at a grand total of $450 Canadian(Including shipping and taxes for shipping). I've swung it around a bit, and believe me, it's a true joy. I personally can't wait to gather up enough money to expand my collection and get together the materials I need for a scabbard and a shield, etc. This forum's a great place for new collectors, too, lots of info.

Definitely go with the Albion Squire Line for your first sword. I know I made the right decision. Cool

Greyson Brown · Posted: Sat 11 Feb, 2006 5:52 pm Post subject:

I feel obligated to reiterate the warning that you have no doubt seen else where. There is one feature of the Albion swords that people tend to overlook... at first. Namely, the Addiction! Your first sword will most definately not be your last. I don't think that is a bad thing; just don't say we didn't warn you. Big Grin

-Grey

Kenton Spaulding · Posted: Sat 11 Feb, 2006 6:00 pm Post subject:

I've got to chime in and agree with Greyson. I only recieved my first Albion yesterday, and all ready I'm scheming up ways to save money for that next (Laird) and next (Crecy) and next (Baron) and next (Sheriff)...get the pic Eek!

That said, they are definitely worth the price IMO, if you can swing it, I would definitely recommend an Albion.

Enjoy

Kenton