[Jean Henri Chandler]

So I think there was an interesting technical / historical discussion emerging about Messers in the Makers and Manufactuters forum, maybe we can continue that here.

I have been interested in attempting to classify these weapons myself and try to determine their role in society and warfare but have found it challenging.

One point of confusion I ran into is that there is a whole family of messer-like weapons which seem to be related, in that they share the following features:

A long single-edged cutting blade
A long handle like a knife handle
A nagel

So I've noticed there seem to be what look like at least 7 distinct types of the 'messer'' family that I've tentatively identified. This mostly applies to the 15th Century when the earliest currently known messer fencing manuals appeared. These namess come from German terms I've seen in historical documents as well as on modern German language auction sites, and these various types all overlap somewhat, which I think has caused some of the confusion around this class of weapons.

The Hauswehr is a long, broad knife with a nagel which was used as the primary home-defense for a farmer or in some cases, a prestige weapon owned by a burgher in Renaisance HRE or Poland. This weapon is shaped like a grossmesser only smaller, with a 12"-16" blade length. I think some of these were made fancy like these from Tods Stuff...



or more simply like this antique


But in both cases had some utility as a tool while being primarily intended as a weapon. Like a bayonett for a 20th Century soldier.

The Baurenwehr is a similar long, broad knife with a nagel which was used as a work-knife by farmers and rural laborers of some distinction or social standing. I think this played a role similar in many respects to what a machete does in Central America today, both as a tool and as a prestige weapon for a certain social class (poor people of some means, essentially). This weapon is shaped like a grossmesser or sometimes is more pointed a lot like an Afghan "khyber knife", except with a nagel. Same size as a Hauswehr.

The Rugger was a hunting knife similar to a Baurenwehr, but specifcially designed for killing and / or skinning animals. These could be larger, average maybe a bit bigger or broader in the blade..



The Coltel (I think related to the Italian term Colatessa and later, possibly to the Cutlass) was also a hunting knife but with a very broad blade, which often did not come to a point, maybe rounded off or squared off. It has a nagel. I think this one is specifically for skinning and butchering animals rather than for killing. Theere are also some of these which look a lot like a bowie knife. Very similar weapons were also used in Burgundy and Northern Spain.




German auction sites refer to these types as ruggers or hauswehrs but I have come to think of them as a distinct subtype

The Grossmesser is the term I specifically apply to the shorter fighting messers, 16-28" long, sometimes with broad blades, such as you see in Durer, sometimes with narrower blades like in Lechkukner . These usually seem to be single-edged with no false-edge.


The Langenmesser is for a longer fighting messer, 28"-36" long, some of these are very long. They usually have a large nagel sometimes a clamshell type, often without quillons but sometimes big quillons like in Talhoffer. They also seem to have some with broad blades (in artwork) and some with quite narrrow blades (antiques at auction sites)

The Kriegsmesser is of course the infamous very large two-handed big war-messer, with a partial false edge and up to 48" long, though most seem to be a bit shorter around 42"-44" or so.



The Kriegsmesser also overlaps with the large Hungarian Infantry Saber (don't know of any period name for this weapon), which is very similar two handed weapon but more curved and with no partial false edge, and with the Schwiesersabel, which is a slender Swiss messer with a complex hilt.

And then you have the Falchion which is a completely different animal I think, and also has many distinct subtypes.

J

[Paul Hansen]

Not at all a bad overview, but I wonder about the distinction between the Hauswehr and the Bauernwehr. I think that these two are essentially the same. The name is also similar: "house defence" and "farmer's defence".

I'm also not sure that I agree with this:

[Christopher Treichel]

Some places also had restrictions and or requirements on the type of Knife Dagger or Sword and weapon/ tool worn by social status in an area...

Many cities hung fake knives next to the city gate so all who entered would know how big a knife they could carry...

What was the local right to defend ones home and what weapons was a propertied person required to maintain?

[Ken Speed]

I agree with Paul in part when he said, "....... but I wonder about the distinction between the Hauswehr and the Bauernwehr. I think that these two are essentially the same. The name is also similar: "house defence" and "farmer's defence"."

I think I disagree with him when he says that these knives weren't tools, it seems to me that some of them were clearly tools and others had evolved from tools to prestige items. That beautifully made broad bladed knife is just a cleaver in party clothes when it comes down to it.

It seems to me that we see a fairly clear line of tools evolving into prestige items and/or weapons here. In the woolier parts of America it was common at one time for a man to have his everyday Bowie and a fancy one for "Sunday Best" or Saturday night. My understanding is that "messer" means knife but in this case it seems that when these implements were referred to as messers they were becoming primarily weapons.

I think the comparison to machetes was somewhat unfortunate and a little misleading, I think the simpler knives can be compared to the Bowie or the Hudson's Bay Knife both a tool and a weapon while fancier and often larger ones were specialized as weapons.

.

[Allen W]

The terms Grossemesser, Langesmasser and Kriegsmesser are interchangeable. The distinction seems to be a very recent result of Albion's naming convention and spread for the sake of having terms to differentiate the categories you site. Of course they could also just be addressed as messers as they are in Talhoffer. Incidently the two-handed messers could have partial back edges and raised back edges as well.

The nagel is not a necessary feature and is as likely to be a side ring instead.

Hauswehr and Bauerwehr are likewise interchangeable as I have seen them used.

I have only seen the term rugger applied to the narrow pointy variety.

Just my experience.

[Paul Hansen]

Regarding the messer / bauernwehr as a tool, I simply do not see the point of carrying something so big and cumbersome. There was no need for a machete-like tool in Europe. There were specialised and much better tools for woodworking, harvesting, pruning etc. So even though a farmer may need a long knife for some tasks, these tasks would not be so frequent that it would make sense to wear this long knife on a belt, as part of daily wear. Also, a tool does not need a cross-guard or a nagel.

To me, a tool is something that belongs in a shed or in a toolbox, and not on a belt, unless it's used extremely often. Like a machete in the rain forest.

I would concede that, like a pocket knife, a messer might occasionally be used as a tool. But then it's a multi-purpose item rather than just a tool. I think that the bowie knife is indeed a reasonable comparison. Anyway, I remain of the opinion that the messer / bauernwehr as discussed here was primarily intended as a self-defence weapon.

[Bill Grandy]

[Jean Thibodeau]

[Mark T]

This thread at SFI contains some discussion that folks might find relevant here: http://forums.swordforum.com/showthread.php?t=56047

[Samuel Bena]

Greetings Jean,
Interesting musing on a somewhat obscure topic