Ebay blues a sad yet sincere venting. -- myArmoury.com

Morgan Butler

Man, it is hard to get antique swords anymore on a limited budget. I work in social services so I have a limited budget to bid with and there is always someone who can drop a bundle like its nothing at all. I recently lost a bid on a very fine CHATELLERAULT FRENCH ARTILLERY SWORD that I liked a lot. I couldnt stick around till the last minute either because I went to fencing. (I had a scheduled lesson) I thought the sword gods migh favor this sincere act but alas the gods of commerce had final judgement. So once more the Sword is an item for rich people. At least its historical. I hope who ever won the sabre (pic below) really appreciates it. Oh sigh of sighs!!!!!!!!!!!! Does anyone else have a sad sword story and pic?

Dan P

Jonathan Eells · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 11:11 am Post subject: Sword Wyrd

I hate losing, too. But the last sword I bought was on an "out-call" basis from the smith. He e-mailed his list of customers, and I didn't read his note until about a half hour after he sent it. I figured "no way, I totally missed it", but I sent back my intent to buy if it was still available. I beat the other guy by TEN SECONDS!

Morgan Butler · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 11:52 am Post subject:

"If you cannot have it, perhaps you dont need it."

Thats probably the truth of it,
I suppose these are the kind of complaints of the petty bougoise. "Boo Hoo, I cant have the antique sword I want." I suppose there are far worse complaints in this world. I should be thankful for the custom swords and antiques that I do have. Still , I really liked that sabre and visualized just where I would put it. I figured myArmoury off topic was the place to express my disappointment with other collectors..

Thom R. · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 12:50 pm Post subject:

I feel your pain. The market for antique everything has been very hot the past year, year and a half. But I have seen this come and go before. Prices do cycle along with the economy. The other compounding problem is of course the dollar which has been really weak against the pound and euro. I am looking at stuff going off this week at Hermann Historica thinking, wow how affordable that would be if the dollar was still at parity with the euro like it was 8 years ago! Today however, ouch!

Morgan Butler · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 1:47 pm Post subject:

And also if yu have specific tastes it can be a while before you find the right thing. I am left handed so I usually look for things with a nice simple d-guard or a symetrical hilt. I am also looking more for weapons that have a scabbard with them. When I think of the swords I owned 15 years ago and let slip thru my fingers I could kick myself.

Glen A Cleeton · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 2:06 pm Post subject:

There was an eagle I was moaning about last month. I had watched it for several years and was within a month of making a firm commitment. Someone found it, or knew of it and beat me to it

Before that, there had really only been a couple I was sad to see go. One Clauberg sabre (of a rather plentiful genre) with a lot of character and an unknown but very nice 18th century horseman's sabre. Both were should have, could have type speculations at the time. One literally lost to a coin toss as to what I bought that year.

I have balanced that with other buys and harvesting images of swords I find interesting. Although I do cruise Ebay just about daily (or moreso), I see too many swords selling for more than they would be even at a lot of higher priced dealers.
I also find some real bargains at dealers and less looked at auction sites. This just came in here yesterday and would have sold for at least half again the asking price on Ebay
http://usera.imagecave.com/Hotspur/Eagles/Ozzycomp.jpg

The week before Easter, I had found an unwanted (not noticed?) auction on Gun Broker for a dirk. Yes, the poor bird was turned around backwards in the auction photos but pursuing that one led to a local guy and I came home with literally two for less than the price of one.
http://usera.imagecave.com/Hotspur/Eagles/Easter9.jpg
http://usera.imagecave.com/Hotspur/Other/Both.jpg

So, in a sense, I have soothed over losing out on the one that got away. Attached below, it is a pretty and different one for sure. I hope to find it went to a good home and may even surface again someday.

As to similar artillery swords, they are around and not that expensive. They may not be that one but lots in terrfic shape. Both French and American made examples. They were used both before and after the ACW, thus not terribly uncommon, once you get past Ebay. There have been some fairly idiotic price/bidding wars in that sector lately. Google has yielded many dozens of dealers and their links lists lead to more.

Cheers

GC

Morgan Butler · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 2:27 pm Post subject:

Whenever I look up sword dealers outside of Ebay, they seem even more expensive and the weapons are not in as good condition.

Glen A Cleeton · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 3:01 pm Post subject:

Morgan Butler · Posted: Wed 09 Apr, 2008 3:15 pm Post subject:

Yes I definately am aware of the same problem of wanting to jump at something else while waiting for something more worthwhile. the rub is when something comes along that I really, really, want- than so does everyone else. Sometimes its a split decision about what I want, what I can afford, and what I can win!