Info Favorites Register Log in
myArmoury.com Discussion Forums

Forum index Memberlist Usergroups Spotlight Topics Search
Forum Index > Historical Arms Talk > Can skills w a short sword translate to use w a long sword? Reply to topic
This is a standard topic  
Author Message
Alex Yeoh





Joined: 01 Nov 2004

Spotlight topics: 1
Posts: 104

PostPosted: Tue 17 Jan, 2006 8:46 pm    Post subject: Can skills w a short sword translate to use w a long sword?         Reply with quote

I'm designing a game system and had a discussion with a buddy about weapon groups, and whether training in one weapon like a short sword can translate into skills with a long sword, thereby making sense for the weapons to be grouped together in a logical fashion. What is everyone's opinion here?

thanks!

"Only a fool would go after the singing sword!" - Bugs Bunny
View user's profile Send private message
Ryan A. C.





Joined: 22 Mar 2004
Reading list: 5 books

Posts: 147

PostPosted: Tue 17 Jan, 2006 9:46 pm    Post subject:         Reply with quote

The long sword is a very versatile weapon and can be used in ways a short sword simply cannot by design. A longsword can be used at the halfsword and is a very affective lever for instance in armoured combat. They are different weapons and will have different strengths and weaknesses given their nature and length. They will want to be used differently, if that maks any sense? I do think certain basic mechanics would transfer from one on to the other however i.e. knowing how to work with distance, timing, strikes.

I'm assuming you mean an arming sword/ single hander?

I hope you get something from this...running on two hours sleep....twenty something hours later...
View user's profile Send private message
Bill Grandy
myArmoury Team


myArmoury Team

Location: Northern VA,USA
Joined: 25 Aug 2003
Reading list: 43 books

Spotlight topics: 2
Posts: 4,194

PostPosted: Tue 17 Jan, 2006 10:41 pm    Post subject:         Reply with quote

Actually, the really beautiful thing about martial arts is that the techniques of single hand sword can be almost exactly the same as a longsword, depending on the system. German messer techniques are almost the exact same techniques as German longsword, right down to the halfswording. There is an extra master strike with Lekuchner's messer, but most of the core strikes are otherwise more or less the same, and most of the tactical use is also executed in the same manner. Messer technique is directly translatable to just about any single hander.
HistoricalHandcrafts.com
-Inspired by History, Crafted by Hand


"For practice is better than artfulness. Your exercise can do well without artfulness, but artfulness is not much good without the exercise.” -anonymous 15th century fencing master, MS 3227a
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Elling Polden




Location: Bergen, Norway
Joined: 19 Feb 2004
Likes: 1 page

Spotlight topics: 1
Posts: 1,576

PostPosted: Wed 18 Jan, 2006 2:00 am    Post subject:         Reply with quote

The SHORT short sword of most fantacy games, (D&D shortsword, Gladius, Ciquenda, viking Sax, katzbalger) has more in common with daggers than swords; they are primarily thrusting weapons, and use those techniques. You CAN hew with them, but the longer weapons are so much better at it that that the dagger style is a lot more favorable.


One handed swords (Broadswords, D&D longswords) and Real Life Longswords use much of the same technique.

However, the one handed sword is most commonly used with a shield or buckler, something the longswordman will not be very good at before he learns to use.

I'd make a group for short stabbing weapons, and one for long bladed weapons

"this [fight] looks curious, almost like a game. See, they are looking around them before they fall, to find a dry spot to fall on, or they are falling on their shields. Can you see blood on their cloths and weapons? No. This must be trickery."
-Reidar Sendeman, from King Sverre's Saga, 1201
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
Bill Grandy
myArmoury Team


myArmoury Team

Location: Northern VA,USA
Joined: 25 Aug 2003
Reading list: 43 books

Spotlight topics: 2
Posts: 4,194

PostPosted: Wed 18 Jan, 2006 10:20 am    Post subject:         Reply with quote

As far as a role playing system goes, I would group short sword and longsword in the same broad category. There are certainly technical differences, but when it comes down to it, the skill sets are more or less the same. It's not like comparing longsword and knife fighting (which have a lot more in common than people give them credit for, but are still distinctly different).

When it comes down to it, if you are proficient with any hand to hand weapon, you will most likely have an idea of how to use most other hand to hand weapons, with the exception of a few outlyers. (e.g. a bullwhip and a sword are very different) So for a game it all depends on how nitpicky you want to be about the rules.

HistoricalHandcrafts.com
-Inspired by History, Crafted by Hand


"For practice is better than artfulness. Your exercise can do well without artfulness, but artfulness is not much good without the exercise.” -anonymous 15th century fencing master, MS 3227a
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Ryan A. C.





Joined: 22 Mar 2004
Reading list: 5 books

Posts: 147

PostPosted: Wed 18 Jan, 2006 10:56 am    Post subject:         Reply with quote

I didn't even notice it was for a games system. Worried

I feel stupid
View user's profile Send private message
Christian Henry Tobler




Location: Oxford, CT
Joined: 25 Aug 2003

Posts: 704

PostPosted: Wed 18 Jan, 2006 11:37 am    Post subject:         Reply with quote

Hi Bill!

Bill Grandy wrote:
Actually, the really beautiful thing about martial arts is that the techniques of single hand sword can be almost exactly the same as a longsword, depending on the system. German messer techniques are almost the exact same techniques as German longsword, right down to the halfswording. There is an extra master strike with Lekuchner's messer, but most of the core strikes are otherwise more or less the same, and most of the tactical use is also executed in the same manner. Messer technique is directly translatable to just about any single hander.


Well...yes and no. There are some fundamental differences that are important to recognize when moving back and forth between these two 'sub-systems'. The one-handed nature of the messer affects timing and leverage in the fight. For instance, the high guard is usually different in what leg leads: vom Tag with the longsword has the left leg leading with the right side version of the guard, while Luginslant with the messer leads with the sword arm side leg. This is because the messer can't provide cover for the body anyway and the hand has to extend more to strike, so the threat is presented earlier.

Some longsword techniques don't work well with the messer, and vice-versa. The messer equivalents of the Schielhau and Scheitelhau are much downplayed by Leckuchner, simply because without the leverage provided by the left hand, they are only so-so blows. This is also why there's a sixth stroke, which moves in a way that the two-handed weapon cannot do well. The messer, for its part, is capable of a greater variety of disarms and grapples by virtue of its shorter length and one-handed play. These differences likely account for why Leckuchner spun his own variant verses for this weapon - there are important concerns to be reckoned with.

Those cautions aside, there's much for a longswordsman to learn from the messer, and vice-versa. The tactical and fighting philosophy framework is consistent.

All the best,

Christian

Christian Henry Tobler
Order of Selohaar

Freelance Academy Press: Books on Western Martial Arts and Historical Swordsmanship

Author, In Saint George's Name: An Anthology of Medieval German Fighting Arts
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address
Bill Grandy
myArmoury Team


myArmoury Team

Location: Northern VA,USA
Joined: 25 Aug 2003
Reading list: 43 books

Spotlight topics: 2
Posts: 4,194

PostPosted: Wed 18 Jan, 2006 12:02 pm    Post subject:         Reply with quote

Hi Christian,
Thanks for the info. I can't wait for the translation of Lekuchner to come out, so I can start actually seriously study the material! Talhoffer, Codex Wallerstein and Kal just aren't good enough, unfortunately. Happy

HistoricalHandcrafts.com
-Inspired by History, Crafted by Hand


"For practice is better than artfulness. Your exercise can do well without artfulness, but artfulness is not much good without the exercise.” -anonymous 15th century fencing master, MS 3227a
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Alex Yeoh





Joined: 01 Nov 2004

Spotlight topics: 1
Posts: 104

PostPosted: Sun 22 Jan, 2006 8:31 am    Post subject: thanks         Reply with quote

Thanks so much for the insight. I guess I have to tread a fine line. Maybe the similarities will translate to the equivalent of a level 1 skill in "similar" weapons - but that's it. To advance beyond level one skill, you must actually train in the individual weapons?

Would this logic translate well to say other weapons like a katana or mace?

Thanks immensely!!

"Only a fool would go after the singing sword!" - Bugs Bunny
View user's profile Send private message
Alex Yeoh





Joined: 01 Nov 2004

Spotlight topics: 1
Posts: 104

PostPosted: Sun 22 Jan, 2006 8:40 am    Post subject: speaking of weapons...         Reply with quote

speaking of weapons, I am trying to devise disadvantages to using a halberd. I'm aware that they are so good that they were used as primary weapon in the battlefield whenever possible.

So what about the disadvantages? I want all my weapons to have mechanics such that you will want to use each and every one of them for their own reasons. I don't want one weapon to have no advantages such that no player ends up using it, and no one weapon so good that it is better than every other weapon.

In the previous version of my game (I am completely revising the entire system), I had halberds simply operate slower. I feel this is not entirely correct, as halberds could be quite fast as well.

What do you guys think of this:

1) Halberds need a lot of room to operate correctly, if there are too many people in the immediate vacinity, the defence capability is reduced
2) Halberds don't work well against more than one opponent. Because of the long nature of the weapon, one enemy could easily grab the long shaft whilst the user was attacking another.
3) any others you can think of?

thanks!!!!!!!!!!!

"Only a fool would go after the singing sword!" - Bugs Bunny
View user's profile Send private message
Elling Polden




Location: Bergen, Norway
Joined: 19 Feb 2004
Likes: 1 page

Spotlight topics: 1
Posts: 1,576

PostPosted: Sun 22 Jan, 2006 9:09 am    Post subject:         Reply with quote

Compared to spears, helbards are not as good at stabbing; the broader heads means that they need larger openings.
They are also generally a bit shorter.

As far as I remember, spears where recomended for attack, while helbariders where better at defence.
This because a spear can "slide" into a enemy formation more efficiently.

Their disadvantage is the absence of a shield, and the weakness against rushing that they share with all polearms.

"this [fight] looks curious, almost like a game. See, they are looking around them before they fall, to find a dry spot to fall on, or they are falling on their shields. Can you see blood on their cloths and weapons? No. This must be trickery."
-Reidar Sendeman, from King Sverre's Saga, 1201
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website MSN Messenger


Display posts from previous:   
Forum Index > Historical Arms Talk > Can skills w a short sword translate to use w a long sword?
Page 1 of 1 Reply to topic
All times are GMT - 8 Hours

View previous topic :: View next topic
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum






All contents © Copyright 2003-2024 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Basic Low-bandwidth Version of the forum