[Ian S LaSpina]

also preordered. If anyone is interested I'd like to recommend The Witcher 2, it's got a very gritty and mature storyline, and even some surprisingly accurate 14th and 15th century armor.

[Joe Fults]

Back scabbards actually killed that game Witcher2 for me.

Silly and a shame but it did!

[Robert Rytel]

Arena was the best. Daggerfall was good despite being unfinished even after the many many patches. Didn't play Redguard much. Battlespire was terrible. The rest were kinda meh. I took one look at the 'glass' and 'chichin' armor, whatever that is, and I quit Morrowind.

[T. Arndt]

Morrowind has been my favorite so far. In my opinion Oblivion was OK, but very generic. Skyrim is looking good!

[Tyler Keich]

[Jeremy V. Krause]

[Nathan Quarantillo]

I for one absolutely love oblivion.
The armour for oblivion I actually found to be quite pleasing, if I could shut off the history nazi in me. It always (except for the absolutely awful deadric) had a quite functional feel and look.

BTW, the steel armour and weapons are actually not to bad on historicity at all. I would simply enchant he heck out of those and use them for the entire game.
The maille armour wasn't too bad too. All in all I loved the game.

[JE Sarge]

Can't stop playing....can't stop playing...must stop....Skyrim! SKYRIM!

Ok, all joking aside, the game is awesome. I am loving it and wasting probably way too much time on it.

[Jeremy V. Krause]

[Emil Andersson]

[Tyler Keich]

The only things I don't like are the Thalmor, and getting caught pick-pocketing with a 90% chance of success.

All my spare time in the past few days has gone to this, I've forgotten the world I came from and am now a Nord in Skyrim.

[Christopher VaughnStrever]

well I traded in 4 other ps3 games and bought skyrim for $13.00 So witht hat said I was pleased to start... and then I started playing and fell asleep playing the game and woke up with the controller in my hands... Ohh just like when I was 18 all over again lol!

Yes it is a great game and the music is lovely. I am happy I can use my shield with a type of "shield bash" and then attack with my sword when the enemy is stunned. I can't stop playing it either.

Just go look at gamestop reviews just about every person has given this game a 10 out of 10

[Myles Mulkey]

This game is seriously absorbing my soul... That's a pun by the way

[Joe Fults]

Sounds like a darn good thing I didn't buy it last weekend.

[William P]

i dont know about dark souls and ive watched people play skyrim, but i have played, and i fell in love with demons souls,

now we can all agree that historical accuracy is hit and miss with that game.
most of the weapons and armour are BASED off historical designs, but there are liberties taken here and there. but not so much that it looks comleately implausible

except with the axes. the only one that wasnt completely and ridiculously oversixed was the crescent axe which was like a egyptian tabar, but with a head twice as big or more.

the mirdan hammer wouldbnt have so big a head normally, and the topspike wouldnt be a ccruciform i.e the cross section of the blade is like a plus +. instead of being a simple diamond profile

the fluted armour seems BASED off maximilian style but tweaks a couple of things,

the katanas arnt magical super swords, but are simply good slashers, but have lower endurence due to the extra hard edge being of course more brittle.

i liked the fact that the broadsword, which was designed with a viking sword in mind, is stated as being a fairly poor thruster, but having a wide blade well suited for cutting strokes,, which is true of type X swords.


t


but what really impressed me about the game was the amount of grip versitility that you could employ.

the fact that you could grip most items in either one or two handed method, and while you couldnt be totally ambidextrous, i.e you couldnt use an item in your left hand the same as you could if it was in your right hand, but it still allowed people, i think we can agree, to replicate a huge number of historical weapon styles, including sword/ shield, or buckler, sword and dagger, two sword, spear or polearm and shield,

the fact that the weight of your equiptment affects your ability to role and sidestep and dodge, i mean, while we all know that plate armour isnt super heavy, the fact is that in leather or cloth armours you can simply move alot more, and while we can role in harness i think. how well CAN we roll and get up again?

but the fact that your general sack doesnt factor into your ability to roll is a mark missed, (runescape actually accounts for all your items when calculating your endurence when sprinting etc)

the ability for shields to parry, or just be used as a wall for example when recieving arrows like you would historically.
but, the fact that simply holding the shield between you and him and lit acting as a wall and simply recieving blows will tire you out, much better to use it to parry and riposte, to create openings,

the fact that some weapons can damage some armours less well than others was a good sign.


the fact that, like in real life you can pick up and even try and fight with weapons too heavy or advanced for you, but, like what happens when you try and use a bow that has a poundage too high for you to handle, your attack damage will be lowered

but the fact that crossbows are close to useless is a shame.



so there we have it.. as you can see, i really like demons souls.

but ive been wondering with skyrim and the horned helmets, while horned helmets are ahistorical, would there be anything particularrly wrong with a horned helmet like that? in terms of practicality?

[Tim M.]

The first thing that comes to mind is that it gives your opponent something to grab onto, although it would add a little more protection from blows to the side of the head I guess from the way they are positioned...

[William P]

[D. S. Smith]

Oblivion was the only other Elder Scrolls game I've played. Skyrim is head and shoulders above Oblivion. Whenever I'm trying to describe it to another gamer, I tell them Skyrim is Fallout 3 set in the fantasy medieval ages. But that's still not doing it justice. The scenery and weather is absolutely stunning. One of my favorite things to do in any roleplaying game is explore. Skyrim makes you want to search every square inch of the map and it is rendered beautifully. The scenery is lifelike, while still having a fantastic element to it.

Here is another huge plus of Skyrim; female characters. Even though I'm a male (although surrounded by females...wife and two daughters ), the computer games I grew up on were Tomb Raider, with Lara Croft. Ever since then I've loved the idea of heroines that could kitt butt and take names, while still being feminine. The downfall of games, however, has been this; You either have female characters with barbie doll proportions and bikini armor, that look like battlefield harlots, or (as in the case of most Bethesda games) you have female characters that look like they fell from the ugly tree and hit every branch on the way down. Then along comes Skyrim, where for the first time in gaming history (that I am aware of) , you can create a heroine that is both attractive, well armored (for battle, not night clubs) and of modest (dare I say realistic) proportions. Even if you choose to give her black eyes...what magician wouldn't want black eyes? ...





Other features I like about Skyrim are the scabbards for single hand swords (they actually stay visible when you draw your sword), and even the armor. For the most part even though the armor is fantasy, it still have the appearance of function, unlike some games where your character runs around with big glowing spaulders on his shoulders.

All in all, for a single player fantasy game, Bethesda has really hit the mark. I think you will be waiting an awful long time for an improvement over Skyrim if single-player roleplaying fantasy is your thing.

[Steven Janus]

[Joe Fults]