Is this really this late?
Is this sword really this late.

It looks like a Mortuary Sword to me...

http://www.cullodenantiques.com/english_officers_back_sword.html

I may be severely mistaken but that what it appears to be to me.
If you're mistaken, I'm probably more so, but don't mortuary swords usually have additional bars going back to the pommel on both sides of the grip?
Regards
Geoff
No, I believe the date on the sword is correct. I've seen this type before.
The dates given for the sword are correct. The hilt is quite striking, and is included in Cyril Mazansky's typology of British basket hilted swords. He would classify it as a Type IV incomplete basket hilt, which is characterized by a heart-shaped stool. The pommel is of type XVA, which is egg-shaped and tapers to the pommel. The first three photos show a similar sword in my collection (the one in my avatar, which has a colichemarde blade of triangular cross section). The fourth photo shows the sword the dealer has referenced.

If you are interested in similar swords (including traditional English and Scottish basket hilts, mortuary swords, etc.), I highly recommend purchasing a copy of Neumann' Swords and Blades of the American Revolution (its scope is greater than just the 1770s and 1780s) and a copy of Mazansky's British Basket-Hilted Swords.


 Attachment: 25.74 KB
DOS.jpg


 Attachment: 25.23 KB
DOS3.jpg


 Attachment: 17.04 KB
DOS4.jpg


 Attachment: 62.43 KB
[ Download ]
BTW--I am sure William (Bill) Goodwin would be happy to clarify what makes a mortuary a mortuary! For now, here is what myArmoury has in the Albums section: Mortuary Hilts. It appears that one distinguishing characteristic is that the mortuary tends to have at least two and often three knuckle guards: the main knuckle guard, and one or two side knuckle guards, which attach to the pommel. The example that inspired this thread has only one knuckle guard--the main knuckle guard--that has branching bars that attach only to the stool (the heart shaped guard), not the pommel.

Also, browsing this section of the National Maritime Museum might turn up some similar examples to the sword that started this thread.

Best,
Jonathan
Martin,

Jonathan H. is spot-on with his assestment. Given the correct time period, it's is a 18th miltiary hanger (English probably)
of sorts. " Mortuary" or English half-baskets were only made a short time between 1635 & 1670.

Nice looking sword there.


Cheers,

Bill
J.G. Hopkins wrote:
Mazansky's British Basket-Hilted Swords.


Is that a Royal Armouries book?

If so there was a copy of it at the market last weekend, i didn't even look at it, i'd already picked up several expensive books....
Martin Wilkinson wrote:
J.G. Hopkins wrote:
Mazansky's British Basket-Hilted Swords.


Is that a Royal Armouries book?

If so there was a copy of it at the market last weekend, i didn't even look at it, i'd already picked up several expensive books....


Yes, it is. It covers the span of basket hilted sword development in England and Scotland and includes what Mazansky calls "incomplete basket hilts", mortuary hilts, and "hilts based on pierced side rings" (which kind of blur the line between mortuary hilts and walloon hilts). It is a book worth saving for! The Neumann book is substantially less expensive, and fortunately is still in print. This book covers American and European swords (meaning mainly England, Scotland, France, and Germany) from c.1600 to c.1800.

Jonathan
Martin,

shop around on E-bay for the Mazansky book....can sometimes pick-it up at a good price.....definitely a must have
for anyone interested in basket-hilts.


Cheers,

Bill
Call me crazy, but don't the prices on some of the items to the Culloden House link you provided look aweful high?

Mike
Michael Mercier wrote:
Call me crazy, but don't the prices on some of the items to the Culloden House link you provided look aweful high?

Mike


I'm no expert in that field. But i'd say they're a little high yeah.

However, i found a link to that site, and decided to see if there was anything pretty...

And there was.

This piece just seemed to be a Mortuary to me, but i now know that it isn't...
William Goodwin wrote:
shop around on E-bay for the Mazansky book....can sometimes pick-it up at a good price.....definitely a must have


I've never seen this particular title on eBay and I look for books every day. I wonder how big the print run was on it. I suspect not very large.
Martin Wilkinson wrote:
This piece just seemed to be a Mortuary to me, but i now know that it isn't...


I can see how one might make that mistake--one that may not be uncommon. For example, the dealer who sold me the sword I posted earlier in this thread (the one in my avatar) thought it was from the 1680s, because to him it resembled English swords of the mid 1600s. Luckily he was not asking the prices commanded by such weapons!

Going back to the Mazansky book, I got a great deal on Amazon--originally $90 USD, I got it on sale for $60 USD. Arms and Armour of the English Civil Wars by David Blackmore is a nice little book, also published by the Royal Armouries. It is much broader in its scope, and will not give you the same depth as the Mazansky title, but I highly recommend it if you have any interest in swords, etc. of the English Civil War period.

Jonathan

Page 1 of 1

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum