Posts: 42 Location: Muscatine, IA, USA
Thu 26 May, 2005 1:27 pm
As a student of the teachings of Liechtenauer, I feel obligated to put in my 2 cents.
First off, defeating an opponent in plate is impossible with a slashing attack. You must use piercing and blunt force attacks to deal any damage. Normally by the 14th and 15th centuries (the period of the armor above), longswords and bastard swords were the standard sword being implimented. Against armored opponents, these swords would be wielded in the "half-sword" style allowing for precise aim and added power during a thrust.
Spears were also a traditional weapon for these time periods and can be weilded proficiently against an armored opponent with deadly results. Though a swordsman still has an advantage over a spear or polearm if they are knowledgable in proper polearm counterattack techniques.
As for disabling an armored oppenent, there are many ways to do this with ease. The first being to strike the hands of your opponent with the tip, otherwise called a Krumpua. This technique is performed from the standard right shoulder position against an opponent swinging from his right side. This technique simply involves stepping to your right and swinging (vertically) at your opponents hands. This has the added bonus of blocking your opponent's attack.
Grappling is a very important part of historical warfare. An armored opponent is weakest when pinned due to his added weight and lack of his weapon. Also disarms can be made against armored opponents just as easily as unarmored opponents.
By the way, mail is not easy to penetrate. Do you think it would have been used for 2000+ years if if couldn't stop a blade? Also, it is not easy to knock over a fully armored opponent. A full plate High Gothic Harness weighs between 60 to 75 pounds, which is evenly distributed over ones entire body. A properly trained individual wearing correctly made armor can do summersaults in full plate without much discomfort.
All my information regarding techniques is taken from "Secrets of German Medieval Swordsmanship" and "Fighting with the
German Longsword." My knowledge of armor comes from personal experiences and researched statements by members of the Arador Armor Library.