Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

No idea. I don't think there are any illustrations showing someone wearing one.
Dan Howard wrote:
No idea. I don't think there are any illustrations showing someone wearing one.


Oh, okay. Thanks anyway!

Personally I'd take a mace as my percussion weapon in a medieval battle. Flails are just too.... Confusing. :confused: (by that I mean "difficult" and you would have to make certain adjustments to wear and fight with them properly)
J. Douglas wrote:

Just wondering- when they were used (rarely, of course) how would they be carried? I

Just with the chain wrapped over a belt.
[ Linked Image ]
Given how impracticable and dangers to the user a flail was, it's easy to see why we barely find them in art or text.

Sure on a theoretical level one can deliver a lot of energy if you can get the ball up to speed.
But how do you do that and stay safe-ish? do you use it like a Short bullwhip? or try helicopter spins over your head?
That's the closest depiction I've seen in artwork of a flail like mine. I've only swung mine once, and can tell you now---the 'short bullwhip' idea is a no-go, and helicoptering it overhead would be just......stupid. :eek: I've taken up some slack in the chain (31") to shorten it, and that makes it semi-useable. There IS NO WAY to get the thing moving quickly, as is. As I stated earlier, I just bought it for the 'wow factor'. This would be THE LAST weapon I would want in a real battle, and it would probably be MY LAST battle due to killing myself with my own weapon! :lol: :lol: It now enjoys a comfy retirement in my 'man-cave' on a shelf behind a locked door...right where it should be. ;) .....Thanks for posting that photo! :D .............McM
Mark Moore wrote:
That's the closest depiction I've seen in artwork of a flail like mine. I've only swung mine once, and can tell you now---the 'short bullwhip' idea is a no-go, and helicoptering it overhead would be just......stupid. :eek: I've taken up some slack in the chain (31") to shorten it, and that makes it semi-useable. There IS NO WAY to get the thing moving quickly, as is. As I stated earlier, I just bought it for the 'wow factor'. This would be THE LAST weapon I would want in a real battle, and it would probably be MY LAST battle due to killing myself with my own weapon! :lol: :lol: It now enjoys a comfy retirement in my 'man-cave' on a shelf behind a locked door...right where it should be. ;) .....Thanks for posting that photo! :D .............McM


The chain is really too long on yours. AFAIK the rule of thumb is that the chain should be short enough that the head cannot reach the hand. So assuming a one handed flail, the chain + head length should be less than the length from the end of the haft to where the grip is.
Yes, I'm aware of that. Thanks. As I said, I CAN shorten up the chain length(using a rock-climbing carabiner) and make it a *little more* user-friendly. ;) It's still dangerous as hell any way you look at it....and looking at it is ALL that should be done with it. It's a display-case queen and always will be. ;) I normally only collect functional weaponry....and functional IT IS...but I just had to have it. :lol: ......McM
I put it in the same league with my Hanwei Lowlander....I don't need a sword as long as I am tall. But, just had to have it simply to make people say "Holy s**t, that's a big sword!". :lol: .....McM
Mark Moore wrote:
I put it in the same league with my Hanwei Lowlander....I don't need a sword as long as I am tall. But, just had to have it simply to make people say "Holy s**t, that's a big sword!". :lol: .....McM

Well, The lowlands could be useful if a punch of armoured soldiers with pikes ever try to besiege your house.

Which is likely to happen... Isin't it? :eek:
Well...In case THAT happens, that's what my Remington 12ga. pump is for. ;) :lol: .....McM
Mark Moore wrote:
Well...In case THAT happens, that's what my Remington 12ga. pump is for. ;) :lol: .....McM


:lol:

Or you could call the police. But the former is a bit funner. :lol:
Just wondering, want are your perffered "blunt" "Hitty" or bludgending weapons? Maces? War hammers? Axes? Poleaxes? Anything else?

Not looking for particular eras, but just what do you think we're the best weapons? (And I guess what do you like aesthetically to)

I personally like maces. Not the spiky morning star ones, though. The flanged and knobbed ones. :D
If you are addressing ME personally, I like axes and war-hammers best. No particular reason....mostly for looks, I guess. My next major purchase will probably be a big Dane-style axe....most likely the big Cold Steel two-hander. :D But...heck....I like 'em ALL. :D :lol: .......McM
Mark Moore wrote:
If you are addressing ME personally, I like axes and war-hammers best. No particular reason....mostly for looks, I guess. My next major purchase will probably be a big Dane-style axe....most likely the big Cold Steel two-hander. :D But...heck....I like 'em ALL. :D :lol: .......McM
nom not you personally. everyone. :D

I mean, Dane axes are amazing! I agree with you on that. It will be a well-worth-it purchase, I'm sure. :D
Dane axes don't help when you are facing an enemy with a line of archers. You need to hope that your neighbour has a shield that is large enough to cover both of you.
I'm in the process of building a Viking shield at this very moment! :D .....McM
:lol: Besides, I only fight the dumb bad guys who don't use archers! :lol: .........McM
Dan Howard wrote:
Dane axes don't help when you are facing an enemy with a line of archers. You need to hope that your neighbour has a shield that is large enough to cover both of you.

Hence no ever seem to have two handed military flails it almost like no one wants to stand near you swing it around.
(The torches and pitchforks brigade often has grain threshing flails but i think it's more visual short hand for angry farmers then a chosen weapon.)

Mark Moore wrote:
There IS NO WAY to get the thing moving quickly, as is.

What's the head/ball's weight roughly ?
I'm just wondering what the moment of inertia is in comparison to mace or a sword.
It is a RitterSteel Authentics , sold by Kult of Athena. They advertise the weight at 5 pound, 13 oz. The handle and chain doesn't amount to that much really...so....I would *guess* that the head alone weighs somewhere between 3-1/2-to-4 pounds. As far as I can tell, the 'ball' is solid--not hollow. It's a meaty chunk of steel....for sure. Suicide on a stick....that's what I call it. :eek: :lol: Comparing inertia to a sword, axe, mace, or ANY other weapon is incalculable, as far as I'm concerned. What I do know is this: Concerning this particular weapon...IF you manage a swift, solid hit...somebody is NOT getting out lightly on the receiving end. ;) Hence all my earlier comments on it....this thing scares the crap outta me. :eek: :wtf: ....McM
Mark Moore wrote:
:lol: Besides, I only fight the dumb bad guys who don't use archers! :lol: .........McM


:lol: I also fight the baddies who don't use shields or spears or archers.

In other words I fight with every Hollywood Army.
Two-handed flails did see serious military use at times, most notably in the Hussite Wars in the 15th century.

Circa 1600 and on (perhaps earlier too), some Korean cavalry used two-handed flails.

As far as Norman maces go, a blow from horseback from a strong and skilled rider would presumably be enough to at least stun any opposing cavalry soldiers. Writing in the first half of the 15th century, Bertrandon de la Broquière thought Turkish cavalry maces would be able to knock a person unconscious through a helmet if the wielder were "swinging freely" (Galen Kline's 1988 English translation). Western European en-at-arms retained the mace until the pistol generally replaced it and transformed heavy cavalry overall.

On the other hand, some Norman maces may have been a bit light compared with 15th-century Turkish maces or 15th/16th-century European maces. I've seen a number of 16th-century maces that are 3+lbs according to museum records, while some earlier maces were only 1-2lbs.
Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

Page 3 of 4

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum