Scott, are you a professional blade maker or a hobby enthusiast?

Please do not take my question as an arrogant attack on you.
It is just that for the discussion about what is a reasonable price, it will really make a big difference if you rely on your livelihood on the craft or if you do it for your enjoyment and fulfillment.

It would be interesting to hear your experiences and observations afterwards. Perhaps a WIP diary, if you are willing to take the time and trouble document the process? That way it would be possible to see what the work flow is and what you invest in the making of a messer that is to hit the 300 USD mark. If you mark the time it takes you to complete the various steps it would help people get an idea of what amount of work is involved in making a "simple" thing like a historically accurate messer.

I say all this without irony and hope it is understood in the way it was intended: an honest wish to see better understanding of the work of the blade maker.

Just a thought. What about a custom messer bare blade for 300?
I mean if the fittings and finish are simple...

Peter, I am far more a hobby enthusiast than a professional. Part of this project is to document the process and try to figure out how I can streamline it. I would be happy to share what I learn, whether from success or failure. Would love to hear any of your further thoughts.

Does anyone have hand-on experience with the Valiant Armoury's Norwich Falchion? At least pricewise it's fairly close.
http://www.customswordshoppe.com/shoppe/produ...ucts_id=52