[G K Vaughn]

The tale of Richard Peeke's quarterstaff duel against three rapier-wielding Spanish soldiers is a popular one amongst HEMA fans, and one that I've regaled many people with over the years, both as evidence for the efficacy of polearms against swords and as a fun story in it's own right.

But it was recently pointed out to me that one part of it is fairly odd, at least by my understanding of polearm construction. Peeke, lacking a quarterstaff, is given the haft of a halberd to fight with. In his own words:

[Ben Anbeek]

Look at this drawing from Hans Talhoffer.

[GG Osborne]

I have an original British artillery halberd in my collection c.1740 where the blade and spike section screws into the socket on the pole. See the example in Peterson's Arms and Armor in Colonial America for an almost exact duplicate of mine.

[Sean Flynt]

I don't understand that at all. "steel," "handle," and "haft" don't really seem interchangeable in this context but they're used as synonyms. As for the "screw," it should be pretty easy to find an example among the surviving halberds of the period if such things existed. I've never seen one, and my own interpretation is that either the socket or langets were secured by screws. In fact, if the halberd did have langets of a piece with the socket, and if they were inset, it would not be possible to screw-on the head. Moreover, I can think of absolutely no reason why an armourer would go the time and expense to create a heavier threaded (cast) socket when the ordinary forged type is naturally more secure. Ditto for the haft. Why cut deep grooves, reducing wood, in the most critical area? On the other hand, it makes good sense to secure langets with screws so that damaged heads and hafts can be easily replaced.

On the other hand...by this time halberds were pale reflections of their 15th and early 16th c. ancestors. They were primarily badges of rank rather than combat weapons, so field impracticality and weakness of construction don't rule out the threaded socket. That would seem to be vanishingly rare, though.

[Bill Grandy]

I have not seen of this kind of construction, but there are enough period weapons that contain similar traits that I would not be too surprised that this existed.

On a separate note, I always caution people from using Peeke's story as fact. It was, after all, written by Peeke, with no one else to confirm or deny his [rather unlikely] story.

[Sean Manning]