Saber similar to katana
Hi, I am a new member here and I have one question. Before three months I find on net few photos of oriental sabre (I don't know it was from Persia or Iran) scanned from any book. The sabre was very similar to katana. Can you say me what is the name of this arm? Thank you very much.
Re: Saber similar to katana
Jakub Oupic wrote:
Hi, I am a new member here and I have one question. Before three months I find on net few photos of oriental sabre (I don't know it was from Persia or Iran) scanned from any book. The sabre was very similar to katana. Can you say me what is the name of this arm? Thank you very much.


could you at least post some fotos of that sabre... otherwise I have no idea which one do you mean.... or a period of its occurrence...
I haven't any photos of this weapon. I don't remember where I found these images. I think that this weapon is from second half of 19th century. Photos was scanned from any book, but I don't remember more.
could you be referring to Hanwei's Dark Sentinal?

It is a similar, but this is not this weapon. Hilt was shorter and blade wasn't so curved. And it wasn't fantasy weapon. Photos were BW and man which bear this weapon have also little shield as a buckler.
I suppose this is kinda random, but what about a tulwar?
[ Linked Image ]
A Swiss Saber, perhaps?
It was not tulwar. I know basic types of sabers, but I haven't seen this weapon before. I remember that this weapon is from Iran or Persia. I think the photos were on any forum about swords, but I'm not sure.
Perhaps it is an Alan sword? A horse people invading western europe ( in 4th or 5th c AD?)
I think this sword is from 5th C, but I have mislaid my notes on this one for the moment. There are also single hand sabers of the Alans that are almost straight and do look rather like katanas in outline of the blade. These are a bit later. At around 7th or 8th C I think.
IŽll post when I find those mages.


 Attachment: 45.42 KB
[ Download ]
i heard once, the japanese were on a westernisation-trip in the late 19th century
and in this context sometimes fittet saber-hilts to katana blades (i don`t know if this is true),
and returened to the real katana in the 1930s with growing nationalism.

maybe this picture really depicts such a "saber-katana" ??
a saber-katana? so basically a sabatana :idea:
Gottfried P. Doerler wrote:
i heard once, the japanese were on a westernisation-trip in the late 19th century
and in this context sometimes fittet saber-hilts to katana blades (i don`t know if this is true),
and returened to the real katana in the 1930s with growing nationalism.

maybe this picture really depicts such a "saber-katana" ??


You are correct, the kyu-gunto has a very western appearance with the sabre hilt mounted on a katana blade. THese came about in the Meiji and Showa times for military use. See attachment.

Sorry for the thread divergence


 Attachment: 58.47 KB
[ Download ]
J Anstey wrote:
Gottfried P. Doerler wrote:
i heard once, the japanese were on a westernisation-trip in the late 19th century
and in this context sometimes fittet saber-hilts to katana blades (i don`t know if this is true),
and returened to the real katana in the 1930s with growing nationalism.

maybe this picture really depicts such a "saber-katana" ??


You are correct, the kyu-gunto has a very western appearance with the sabre hilt mounted on a katana blade. THese came about in the Meiji and Showa times for military use. See attachment.

Sorry for the thread divergence


that actually looks pretty nice
yes, thats quite interesting. maybe jakub meant one of these.
some officers kyu gunto were very nice although I have always found the concept to be quite bizarre.

[/img]


 Attachment: 111.8 KB
DSC00642.JPG.jpeg

Thank you very much. I saw another weapon, but the type was the same. I'm your payer.
Peter Johnsson wrote:
Perhaps it is an Alan sword? A horse people invading western europe ( in 4th or 5th c AD?)
I think this sword is from 5th C, but I have mislaid my notes on this one for the moment. There are also single hand sabers of the Alans that are almost straight and do look rather like katanas in outline of the blade. These are a bit later. At around 7th or 8th C I think.
IŽll post when I find those mages.


Hi Peter,
It took a while but I managed to find this sword in "Attila und die Hunnen".

It's from Kurgan 2, Brut, North Ossetia, Caucasus, and thought to be of Alan origin, dating approx. 4th-5th. C.

So you have pretty good memory. ;)

It's double edged though...
Are you perhaps talking about a saber such as number 794? It's description is:

"Sabre from Szekes-Fejervar, Hungary, 10th-11th centuries (National Museum, Budapest, Hungary)
This beautiful sabre has a non-tapering blade with an angled tip. In many respects it recalls some fine, and very much later, Japanese swords. The origins of both groups of weapons almost certainly lay in Central Asia. The bulbous quillons are of an unusual and probably early form."

[ Linked Image ]
I hope this helps,
Dan


(image taken from David Nicolle's, Arms & Armour of the Crusading Era 1050-1350: Western Europe and the Crusader States)

Page 1 of 1

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum