Go to page Previous  1, 2

It seems that up until armour became commonplace for profesional soldiers, one would throw whatever was handy. Rocks, spears, maces, even swords in some cases.
However, it does not seem like dedicated throwing axes where a big hit.

One reason could be compability with the other equipment in use. In a shield wall context, getting a hit past the enemy shields could be hard. Spears would be more likely to slip through small openings. Further more, a short axe like the francisca would not serve very well as a hand weapon in a shield wall, while a spear can be used for stabbing as well.

In later periods, when plate armour dominate, there isn't much point in throwing stuff at all.
I realize that this is an SCA-ism, so please don't mistake this for historical commentary. It's just an observation.

Hand axes are marvelous tools for hooking and displacing shields, so that spears behind the shieldwall and do their work. I carry a two small axes (one in my hand before the battle begins, and one tucked in my enarming straps) and a short sword.

I fave found that throwing axes in coordinated volleys is ineffective because the enemy sees it coming and turtles up. behind their shields. I suspect the same would be true for arrow volleys.

What works far better is to wait for a lull in the fighting, look for an opponent who isn't scanning or is distracted, and fire an axe at his face.

I also love to throw real axes, one of the cool (or scary) things about thrown weapons is that they bounce in weird ways, and there's no good way to get hit with a thrown axe. The bit might skip off of your helmet, fly left at a right angle, and the handle could break the nose of some random dude behind you. I can only imagine what hundreds of axes thrown at once would to to a poorly armored fyrd.
Gavin Kisebach wrote:

I also love to throw real axes, one of the cool (or scary) things about thrown weapons is that they bounce in weird ways, and there's no good way to get hit with a thrown axe. The bit might skip off of your helmet, fly left at a right angle, and the handle could break the nose of some random dude behind you. I can only imagine what hundreds of axes thrown at once would to to a poorly armored fyrd.


I enjoyed the couple of time that I got to try throwing "hawks" as well.

I am puzzled about your assessment of axes (in the sense of franciscas) not working in volleys. If they really did cartwheel, it seems like it would be tough for an opposing line to deal with them if they were thrown at a variety of heights (Some aimed at heads and chests, some aimed at legs, with unpredictable shield position needed to deal with the cartwheeling projectiles...if that really was how they worked.) Anyhow, I would have to agree that a slung stone, axe/ club like object, or even a two pound rock impacting early medieval mail, arms or legs unexpectedly would be unpleasant.
They don't work in the SCA context largely because there's not enough of them being thrown, and people aren't really afraid of taking an axe to the face, so the psychological element isn't there. Of course I've kept archers and spearmen ducking for cover over and over by pump faking, so there's something to be said for the fear factor.

Our first experiments went poorly because everyone instinctively threw at the opponent directly opposite them. Some things that make volleys better are throwing over the first few ranks so that people who feel safe get whacked, and throwing axes diagonally to your right, which goes into the enemy's less shielded sword side.

Throwing the axes sidearm seems to work better against a shallow formation like a shieldwall, because you tend to error left and right as opposed to up and down. If you miss your mark, you'll probably hit the guy next to him. An overarm throw is great against big blocks of infantry, but tends to sail right over a shallow shield wall.

Again, just observations and totally ahistorical.
Not Western European, but here are some pages with information on the fighting axes and hammers popular in Eastern Europe and the Steppes, many of which appear like they could be effective throwing weapons:

http://www.redkaganate.org/martial/weapons/axehung.shtml

http://www.redkaganate.org/martial/weapons/axerus.shtml
Go to page Previous  1, 2

Page 2 of 2

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum