Matthew Amt wrote: | ||
Hoo, it's a tough question, and not a new one! Mail was around for about 300 years before the segmentata appeared in the late first century BC, and mail was still widely used all through the 3 centuries of the segmentata's use. And of course it was THE favorite form of armor after that. There are those who claim that segmentata was just some oddball thing that is over-represented, or that it was "engineer armor" worn only for sieges, etc. I'd have to say that's bunk. I don't think it was worn by *all* legionaries, by any means, but artwork like Trajan's Column show that legionaries in segmentata was a ROMAN stereotype, and there must have been a reason for that. It's significant to note that we do NOT have evidence for officers of any sort wearing segmentata. Centurions, standard bearers, and musicians are all depicted in mail or scale armor. Tribunes and legates of course wear the Hellenistic-style muscled cuirass. Oddly, we don't see auxiliary infantry or cavalry wearing segmentata, either, though we do find pieces of it in forts that were garrisoned by auxiliaries. (Though we can't rule out the presence of legionary detachments--but beware of circular arguments!) But aside from that, we have no real indication of why some troops might have worn segmentata and others wore mail. It could very well have depended much on personal preference--even among reenactors, many will strongly prefer one over the other. I love my segmentata, don't get me wrong, and I love stabbing it with my pugio to show the kids that "armor works", but I suspect that if I had to be armored on almost a daily basis, I might opt for the mail. It's just too easy to wear and maintain, by comparison. Not sure if that answers your question? Though I do prefer to question answers, obviously, ha! Matthew |
Trajan column was column to commemorate the Roman legion feating the Dacians, I'm not saying it was a rare thing, we have t o many exacuations of segmentata to say tha. But you have to remember that Trajan's was first and formost a political proganda piece to show the might of the Emperor and his army to the people of Rome and it's enemies. I'm not saying that segmentata was rare but I wouldn't be surprised if there was alot less segmentata in a Roman legion than depicted with the expection of the Dacians and the Parthians, most of Romes enemies didn't have weapons that mail couldn't stand up to and the longetivy, flexibility (escpecially for calvary units) sizing ease and maintense ease makes much easier for large Armytraveling such vast distances in a variety of weather and on foot.