[Johnson T.]

Hey folks!

1. What are these pauldron guards I see reenactors wear (see them below)?
2. In the movie called Ivanhoe (1953), Robert Taylor wears a coif which is flat at the top. How is this done and is it accurate to any specific period? Looks good, was it used?

3. Can someone reveal what these strange decorative bands worn over coifs are and provide info about their use? Are they a ren fair thing?


Thanks.

[Stephen Curtin]

Hi Johnson, well those "pauldrons" weren't actually for protection, they were a purely decorative/armourial piece called aillettes and often made from parchment I believe. Both the head bands and the flat topped coifs were intended to hold the helm in the right place and to lift up slightly so that impacts weren't transferred to the head, similar to the suspension systems on modern hard hats. The flat topped coif was achieved by having a padded arming cap underneath and AFAIK were popular in the late 13th, early 14th century. Hope this helps.

[Mart Shearer]

1. Ailletes seem to have been popular from c.1280-c.1350. Their primary function seems to be heraldic display and identification from the side, though they offer limited shoulder protection. None of the period monuments or art seem to show the "through-lacing" used by the reenactors in your photographs.

2. The flat looking coif was likely accomplished through the use of a padded arming cap worn under the mail, though it is possible that the mail was worn over an iron helmet. The effigy of William Longespee (Longsword) the elder shows this in the 1220s, and the Wells Cathedral knights from the 1230-1240s seem to have similar profiles from arming coifs over the mail.

http://effigiesandbrasses.com/static/monument..._r1588.jpg

http://effigiesandbrasses.com/monuments/?name...;view=list

I suspect the look faded as helms lost that big flat top to a more tapered design after 1260 or so. The decorative ring over the coif seems to an odd interpretation of both straps--often woven through the mail to keep the coif tight to the brow but sometimes external, or the padded ring on the arming coif seen at Wells.

[Doug Lester]

Those rolls of cloth worn over the coif were to hold the helm or helmet off the head. If the helm rested directly on the head or right over the coif it would give no protection from a blow. The force would be transmitted directly to the head. It would serve the same purpose as the webbing or plastic straps inside a modern hard hat.

To get the shape of the coif that Robert Taylor was wearing it would have to be worn over the helmet. It might have been a more comfortable way to wear the coif but I'm not sure about the historical accuracy of the practice.

[Brian Robson]

[Randall Moffett]

My guess is padding but this is tied to some level of estimation. We have the Temple Church, London effigy from mid 13th appears to show a heavy ring roll around the top and no coif on yet (maybe to keep from hidding the wearers face if the mail comes up over it, as the helmet would as well so it is also not on). You also can see some wearing this over the coif such as at Wells Cathedral from around the time. As far as I know there are some helmets that are shown that likely were under mail but I know of only rounds. So possible for a angular one like these, sure. We see more of them in art. It could be both were done but my money is still on the padded under coif being more common than the steel helmet. Now this is only based on art as well but none of the manuscripts I know of talk about this really.

RPM

[Mart Shearer]

The only text I can think of mentioning a cervelliere and mail coif comes from the Modus armandi milites ad torneamentum of c. 1325-1330. Per Dr. Sydney Anglo in The Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe, pp.205-6