http://www.myArmoury.com/talk/viewtopic.php?t=20025
I've wanted a D pommel for my collection for quite some time (indeed I've owned a couple but they did not satisfy). There are a few very nice production pieces out there, but none of them seem to exactly match what one sees in the originals, for one reason or another.
Looking at the above thread one notices a group with very similar characteristics (see examples below): a very similar long thin blade (37-38") of Oakeshott type Xa/XI (Geibig 13), a straight cross (usually type 1, but at least one type 2), a single-hand grip, and a nearly identical type D pommel. These swords seem quite clearly to be built for use from the back of a horse - long reach, but likely awkward in close quarters. Moreover, they share so many common characteristics that one is tempted to say, to paraphrase Oakeshott, 'they were made in the same workshop, if not by the same hands'.
This notion gave rise to a concept for a custom piece.
I took this notion to Craig Johnson at A&A and asked him to make me one of these swords, as if it were the next one to roll out of this 13th century 'assembly line' , choosing some of the features from the known examples that I prefer. In particular, I chose the slighlty unusual rounded type 1 spikehilt cross from one of the examples shown below, wanted the pommel to have the slightly scaloped bottom missing from most modern replicas, and of course the full length blade.
This project has now come together and over the next days we'll see the results.
By the way, there is talk of turning this into an A&A production piece, so I'm sure Craig will be interested to see what people have to say about it.









