Go to page 1, 2  Next

Aegean Bronze Age Sword Charts w/ Abstract from Sandars
Hi All...

I wanted to share the Aegean Bronze Age Sword typology chart I put together a few years ago trying to combine the classification systems of N.k. sandars and Imma kilian-Dirlmeier into one graphic. I have also developed charts for each type category. On these charts I have tried to abstract some of the conclusions from N.K. Sandars landmark articles on the subject published in the American Journal of Archeology (AJA).

N.K. Sandars, "The First Aegean Swords and Their Ancestry" (in AJA v.65) and
N.K. Sandars, "Later Aegean Bronze Swords" (in AJA v.67)

The information on the Kilian-Dirlmeier classification system, as with many of the examples in the charts, are from
Imma Kilian-Dirlmeier, "Die schwerter in griechenland, Bulgarien und Albanien" in Prahistorische Bronzefunde, abteilung IV Band 12

I invite any corrections or suggestions for improvement in these charts. (I have these stored in photoshop and can make changes easily,)

I believe that swords of the Aegean Bronze Age (as with those in the Nordic Bronze Age) are some of the the most beautiful and distinct swords ever discovered.

I hope these charts may be of assistance in helping you understand the theories on origins and trends in the development of Aegean Bronze Age swords.

Take care,

ks


 Attachment: 148.33 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 148.44 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 148.98 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 148.02 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 149.36 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 148.74 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 149.42 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 149.35 KB
[ Download ]
Here are the rest...

ks


 Attachment: 146.9 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 148.82 KB
[ Download ]

 Attachment: 147.06 KB
[ Download ]
Wow - beautiful, wonderful, a great tool. If they haven't already, they should be published in a monograph.
Very nicely done. I can see that much thought and consideration went into these layouts. I am unfamiliar with these types of swords, and your charts have sparked an interest! Keep up the great work.
Whoa... :eek:
That looks like a lot of hard work and effort right there.
Sweet job! :lol:
I'd better get to saving these bad boys at some point.
Great Stuff!!!
This is really excellent work Kirk. Great Job. Very accessible and Interesting.

Thank you
Craig
Really nice work Kirk! Thanks!
Kirk, it always feels like Christmas day when you post. I love clear illustrations almost as much as I like typology charts. Thanks for putting these up.
I find this work interesting and rare.
Thank you, Kirk, for adding this here.
Ciao
Gavin Kisebach wrote:
Kirk, it always feels like Christmas day when you post...



Thanks guys...


Hey Gavin... I'm trying to put together a seax typology chart... I'll try to post it on Christmas :eek: ;) :D

take care

ks
Kirk,
Are you still here in DFW? I have quite a few photos of Bronze Age Aegean swords from various museums I've visited recently (Royal Ontario, Met, Allard Pierson, Onassis, etc.). I'm still in the process of uploading most of them, but next time Tom Carr has one of his "sword parties" remind me to bring my thumbdrives; I'm sure the photos and labels will prove useful to your system.

http://forensicfashion.com/BC2000CycladicWarrior.html

The Pierson especially is an under-appreciated resource, given its very impressive holdings and abundance of weapons, and the overall quality of its displays.
Kirk this is really good stuff. Thanks so much. tr
Bronze rapier with ivory, pommel and gold collars on the grip. A double row of connected spirals in relief on the central rib of blade.
From "Chieftan's Grave", cemetery of Zafer Papoura, Crete.
Total length 95,5 cm.
Late 15th century B. C.
(Archeol. Mus. Heraklion, Crete).

In the Mediterranean group we find the thrusting sword in the
shape of a rapier , with a leafshaped, pistil blade and a
pronounced point, or the so called carp's tongue point, as a very important
object used by footmen.

Arthur J. Evans: The prehistoric tombs of Knossos. (Archaeologia
1903. Vol. 59, p. 445 ff)

I hope is a little help
Ciao
Maurizio


 Attachment: 74.48 KB
Senza titolo-2.jpg

Ruel A. Macaraeg wrote:
Kirk,
Are you still here in DFW? I have quite a few photos of Bronze Age Aegean swords from various museums I've visited recently (Royal Ontario, Met, Allard Pierson, Onassis, etc.). I'm still in the process of uploading most of them, but next time Tom Carr has one of his "sword parties" remind me to bring my thumbdrives; I'm sure the photos and labels will prove useful to your system.
...



Yeah... sounds great!

I'll send you a PM and maybe we can meet up. I have a couple more Cervenka's to show you and just about to finish my Mindelheim too.


take care

ks
Thom R. wrote:
Kirk this is really good stuff. Thanks so much. tr


Hey Thom...

You are certainly welcome :)

ks
Maurizio D'Angelo wrote:
Bronze rapier with ivory, pommel and gold collars on the grip. A double row of connected spirals in relief on the central rib of blade.
From "Chieftan's Grave", cemetery of Zafer Papoura, Crete.
Total length 95,5 cm.
Late 15th century B. C.
(Archeol. Mus. Heraklion, Crete).

In the Mediterranean group we find the thrusting sword in the
shape of a rapier , with a leafshaped, pistil blade and a
pronounced point, or the so called carp's tongue point, as a very important
object used by footmen.

Arthur J. Evans: The prehistoric tombs of Knossos. (Archaeologia
1903. Vol. 59, p. 445 ff)

I hope is a little help
Ciao
Maurizio


Hi Maurizio...

Great stuff.

I'll see your 95 cm and raise you a 116 cm

It is from Zapher Papoura Knossos Crete. Total length 116 cm. (That is a bronze sword as long as a medieval longsword!) It is preserved in the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford England and published in Sandars,N.K."Later Aegean Bronze Swords" AJA. V67

I still do not know how you can have such a long slight bronze blade and not have it bending all over the place, even with such a thick cross section :?:

take care

ks


 Attachment: 140.83 KB
FH.Horn1b.L116bl73.ZapherPapouraKnossosCrete.AMO.SLAB.jpg
preserved in the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford England and published in Sandars,N.K."Later Aegean Bronze Swords" AJA. V67
Kirk Lee Spencer wrote:


Hi Maurizio...
Great stuff.
I'll see your 95 cm and raise you a 116 cm
ks


Hi Kirk,
you consider that the book is referenced Hoffmeier, it is 1903. All this time you should be lengthened. :eek:
kidding Kirk. here my source of information. Your information seems more reliable.
is truly incredible ... 116 cm bronze. Without fear these ancient warriors. :)
Ciao
Maurizio


 Attachment: 159.69 KB
Senza titolo-2.jpg

Kirk Lee Spencer wrote:
I still do not know how you can have such a long slight bronze blade and not have it bending all over the place, even with such a thick cross section :?:


I don't know, but the cross section *is* thick. ;)

Maybe you should contact Brock, he has a replica of this type. IIRC, it is about a meter long or so...
Maurizio D'Angelo wrote:
Kirk Lee Spencer wrote:


Hi Maurizio...
Great stuff.
I'll see your 95 cm and raise you a 116 cm
ks


Hi Kirk,
you consider that the book is referenced Hoffmeier, it is 1903. All this time you should be lengthened. :eek:
kidding Kirk. here my source of information. Your information seems more reliable.
is truly incredible ... 116 cm bronze. Without fear these ancient warriors. :)
Ciao
Maurizio



Hey Maurizio...

Good one :D

I think the source information is fine, we are just looking at two different swords from the same cemetery.

take care...

ks
Paul Hansen wrote:
Kirk Lee Spencer wrote:
I still do not know how you can have such a long slight bronze blade and not have it bending all over the place, even with such a thick cross section :?:


I don't know, but the cross section *is* thick. ;)

Maybe you should contact Brock, he has a replica of this type. IIRC, it is about a meter long or so...



Hi Paul...

I have heard about his Ci... Not sure if I have seen it yet. I know that if Neil cast it, then it will be a fine piece. I'll have to get one of these from Neil. First I have to finish my Mindelheim and Limehouse :) Speaking of the Mindelheim, the other day I got the pommel on the Mindelheim and was surprised that I can actually find the center of percussion on this long bronze blade. It vibrates like steel and has a nice "ring" to it.

For some reason, in my mind I see these extremely long bronze swords as King's swords that were probably prestige items and not used for combat unless absolutely necessary, or maybe some kind of kingly duel. I suppose they could also be used in combat. The long point would be great for getting over the opponent's shield.

take care

ks


 Attachment: 65.45 KB
MinoanDuel6_jpg024.jpg

Go to page 1, 2  Next

Page 1 of 2

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum