Posts: 144 Location: Tallahassee, Fl
Wed 21 Sep, 2005 11:54 am
Hi Daniel,
I just tested it for edge retention again, and it does hold a good edge. The test was to perform 50 3/8" deep cuts into some old 3/16" thick leather (not very supple. Quite abrasive as far as leather goes) with only the last 1" of the blade, and then have that portion still shave, and it passed just fine. Honestly, I couldn't tell a difference from how it was before I started.
I know you are quite knowledgeable, I'm *not* trying to insult your intelligence, but I do want to make sure that I make some things clear before you decide, so here are some things to know before using it for your intended purpose:
It will take a considerable amount of upkeep compared to your run of the mill stainless knife with a plastic handle. I've soaked it repeatedly with linseed oil, put quite a bit in it actually, but it won't hold up to a dishwasher. The spacer between the blade and handle is leather. Soaked in linseed oil, but it's still leather, so after washing it will need to dry thoroughly. We have a couple kitched knives that we use that have leather spacers, and have never had a problem, other than when I forget to dry them Also, since the wood is spalted, there are some pin holes in the wood that I could address that are fine for about anything other than dedicated food preparation.
Here is a diagram I just made showing the construction. Notice that the full width of the tang does enter the buttcap, only the very peened end has a smaller diameter of about 1/8".
Having said all that, I personally wouldn't hesitate to use it as a kitchen knife. The wrought iron should get a really nice patina to it. That would be really cool for you to use it like that, actually. The edge is fairly aggressive with slicing due to the stratification of the layers.