myArmoury.com - Flat or round rings for riveted mail?

Posts: 27 Location: Minnesota, USA

Sat 02 Jan, 2016 4:47 pm

Flat or round rings for riveted mail?

I'm starting a project to make a haubergeon of riveted mail and wanted to ask some people if it would be better to have completely flattened rings or rings that are only flattened on the overlap. I think it may be harder to only flatten the one portion but I have heard from some that fully flattened rings are less historically accurate. Thanks in advance for any and all answers on the topic. Also if anyone could suggest a method for cutting the rings without modifying a set of wire cutters?

Profile PM

Mart Shearer

Quote

Posts: 1,303 Location: Jackson, MS, USA

Sat 02 Jan, 2016 5:35 pm

Re: Flat or round rings for riveted mail?

Thomas R-W wrote:

I'm starting a project to make a haubergeon of riveted mail and wanted to ask some people if it would be better to have completely flattened rings or rings that are only flattened on the overlap. I think it may be harder to only flatten the one portion but I have heard from some that fully flattened rings are less historically accurate. Thanks in advance for any and all answers on the topic. Also if anyone could suggest a method for cutting the rings without modifying a set of wire cutters?

Better in what way? If you're aiming for historic accuracy, it depends on the time frame. If you're asking which is easier to pierce for riveting, you get a different answer. If your definition of better is using the fewest steps, you get a third answer.

Profile PM

Thomas R-W

Quote

Posts: 27 Location: Minnesota, USA

Sat 02 Jan, 2016 5:38 pm

Re: Flat or round rings for riveted mail?

Mart Shearer wrote:

Better in what way? If you're aiming for historic accuracy, it depends on the time frame. If you're asking which is easier to pierce for riveting, you get a different answer. If your definition of better is using the fewest steps, you get a third answer.

Then I guess I'll hear all three answers.

Profile PM