myArmoury.com - "Wavy" blades on Lutel two-handers?

Posts: 20 Location: Norway

Fri 12 Dec, 2003 2:48 pm

"Wavy" blades on Lutel two-handers?

Hi, all

Lutel has something they call a "wavy" blade on a couple of their two-handers. It appears that the blade itself actually has the general shape of waves close to the quillon block. Their pictures do not show how far these waves go down the blade.

Not knowing much about medieval two-handers I ask: is this historic in any way? It's a bit surprising to me if swords of the 16th century had such a hard-to-produce feature, but I'm no expert. Wouldn't this weaken the sword?

Comments or clarifications appreciated, thanks,

Borger

Attachment: 45.85 KB

Profile PM

Thomas McDonald

Quote

Posts: 2,160 Location: New Hampshire

Fri 12 Dec, 2003 3:07 pm

From ARMA 's site :

The Flamberge

An unusual waved-bladed rapier popular with officers and upper classes during the 1600s. It was considered to look both fashionable and deadly as well as erroneously believed to inflict a more deadly wound. When parrying with the flamberge, the opponent's sword was slowed slightly as it passed along the length. It also created a disconcerting vibration in the other blade. The term flamberge was also used later to describe a dish-hilted rapier with a normal straight blade. Certain wave or flame-bladed two-handed swords have also come to be known by collectors as "flamberges", although this is inaccurate. Such swords are more appropriately known as "flammards" or "flambards".

[ Linked Image ]

http://www.thehaca.com/spotlight.htm

[ Linked Image ]

Profile PM Website

Nathan Robinson

Quote

Posts: 11,553 Location: San Francisco

Fri 12 Dec, 2003 4:02 pm

Profile PM E-mail Website

Björn Hellqvist

Quote

Posts: 723 Location: Sweden

Fri 12 Dec, 2003 4:17 pm

Hi, Borger! As for the Lutels, they are less wavy than their historical counterparts, but the waves go all the way down to the point. The wavy zweihänders are quite manageable. The pic shows some Swedish ARMA guys testing zweihänder vs pikes. You can just see the waves in the blade.

Attachment: 20.43 KB

Profile PM Website

Gabriel Stevens

Quote

Posts: 145 Location: St. Louis

Fri 12 Dec, 2003 9:09 pm

Here's some from the St. Louis art museum.

Attachment: 12.94 KB

Profile PM E-mail Website

Gabriel Stevens

Quote

Posts: 145 Location: St. Louis

Fri 12 Dec, 2003 9:10 pm

And the other, a little more applicable to this post....

Attachment: 25.89 KB
[ Download ]

Profile PM E-mail Website

Borger Kruge

Quote

Posts: 20 Location: Norway

Sat 13 Dec, 2003 1:29 pm

Wow, thanks for all the input, guys, and especially to Mr McDonald explaining the actual purpose of the waves. And I suspected this to be some sort of a "fantasy" feature. Shame on me :surprised:

Borger

Profile PM

Lafayette C Curtis

Quote

Posts: 2,698 Location: Indonesia

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 9:11 am

Hm. Don't the pikemen's postures in the ARMA photograph look a little bit odd? I've never really seen anybody do either the "charge" or "high charge" that way.

I doubt it would have made much difference, though. What could have made a difference is if the pikemen were moving, since they could have bowled over the two-handed swordsman by the sheer force of their rush.

Profile PM

Jean Henri Chandler

Quote

Posts: 1,420 Location: New Orleans

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 10:21 am

Borger Kruge wrote:

Wow, thanks for all the input, guys, and especially to Mr McDonald explaining the actual purpose of the waves. And I suspected this to be some sort of a "fantasy" feature. Shame on me :surprised:

Borger

I'm not sure the jury is out on the purpose of the 'waves'. Thats one theory, the fact is they really don't know. Another theory is that the wave like shape of the blade makes an effect kind of like serration, enhancing the effectiveness of a draw-cut. This jibes with the fact that these wave blades appear most often on the 'true' two-handers and on rapiers; both weapons which are tricky to use effectively in a clinch. Enhancing the draw-cut literally gives you another weapon when at very close range, and also makes it more risky for an opponent to grab your blade.

Jean

Profile PM

Jean Henri Chandler

Quote

Posts: 1,420 Location: New Orleans

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 10:24 am

Björn Hellqvist wrote:

Hi, Borger! As for the Lutels, they are less wavy than their historical counterparts, but the waves go all the way down to the point. The wavy zweihänders are quite manageable. The pic shows some Swedish ARMA guys testing zweihänder vs pikes. You can just see the waves in the blade.

Thats very interesting Bjorn, thanks for posting that. I wanted to ask, was there any attempt made to cut the 'pikes' ? I would love to see some light shed on this debate over wheather zwiehanders could cut of pike -heads.

We did a kind of similar test here in New Orleans about two weeks ago, I had a colleague hold a 14' wooden pole (I'm not sure what kind of wood it was) and I cut it with my Albion constable. I had no problem cutting through it, in fact I 'carroted' it, cutting off 4 or 5 small pieces in rapid succession. Unfortunately we didn't have the camera at the time, I'm planning to try this experiment again and film it as soon as I can find another long pole like that.

J

Profile PM

Steve Grisetti

Quote

Posts: 1,812 Location: Washington DC metro area, USA

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 3:35 pm

Jean Henri Chandler wrote:

Björn Hellqvist wrote:

Hi, Borger! As for the Lutels, they are less wavy than their historical counterparts, but the waves go all the way down to the point. The wavy zweihänders are quite manageable. The pic shows some Swedish ARMA guys testing zweihänder vs pikes. You can just see the waves in the blade.

Thats very interesting Bjorn, thanks for posting that. I wanted to ask, was there any attempt made to cut the 'pikes' ? I would love to see some light shed on this debate over wheather zwiehanders could cut of pike -heads.

I'm not Björn Hellqvist (he hasn't posted here since May of 2005, btw), but wanted to comment. I wasn't aware of a debate over whether zweihanders could cut pike heads off. I just received a book on the Landsknechts over the holidays, which says that the main purpose for the front line of doppelsöldner, equipped with the zweihanders, was to do exactly that.. (The book is one of the Osprey series, Men-at-Arms No. 58, so, I know everything in it shouldn't be taken for absolute fact.)

Quote:

We did a kind of similar test here in New Orleans about two weeks ago, I had a colleague hold a 14' wooden pole (I'm not sure what kind of wood it was) and I cut it with my Albion constable. I had no problem cutting through it, in fact I 'carroted' it, cutting off 4 or 5 small pieces in rapid succession.

Sounds impressive - how thick was the pole? I guess the kind of wood used would be an important variable, but one of those Landsknecht zweihanders might be able to wack a pike with a lot more impact than the Constable, just due to sheer size.

Profile PM

Michal Grosenbach

Quote

Posts: 7 Location: Elgin, IL USA

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 7:00 pm

Hey Borger,

Concerning your Q on weakening the blade, I'd say "yep", especially the Zweihander, due to the tight radii. It would just create stress points or additional weight to reinforce them, I'm thinkin'... which is possibly why modern repro's have more gradual waves...?

Profile PM

Jean Thibodeau

Quote

Posts: 8,310 Location: Montreal,Quebec,Canada

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 7:21 pm

Michal Grosenbach wrote:

Hey Borger,

Concerning your Q on weakening the blade, I'd say "yep", especially the Zweihander, due to the tight radii. It would just create stress points or additional weight to reinforce them, I'm thinkin'... which is possibly why modern repro's have more gradual waves...?

I would agree that if the arcs meet and change direction suddenly at one very small point: If they meet and form a small radius there would be less of a stress riser and if the blade undulate with convex and concave arcs of about the same length and staggered so that a convex on one side of the blade corresponds to a concave on the other side there should be no points of concentrated stress.

Profile PM

Steven H

Quote

Posts: 545 Location: Boston

Fri 05 Jan, 2007 11:02 pm

cuting off pike heads

I would suggest that pike heads could be cut-off by large swords.
And that they couldn't.

A general overview of spear and pike development starts without langets and moves to some langets, to subtantial langets. For the period of European pike use (as opposed to Greek). I believe that most pikes had multiple steel or iron langets. It seems logical that langets were added because without them the poles could be damaged or broken.

So I reason that originally, polearm heads could be cut by large swords, other polearms etc.

But then the question is whether or not the zweihander could cut a plate of iron backed by and inch of ash and reinforced with three other plates of iron. That seems far less likely to me (effectively impossible because it would so unlikely to succeed that trying would be counter-productive).

I'm not aware of any historical evidence to suggest that zweihanders were used to cut pike-heads off, even if they could. Though I know of multiple admonitions by fight masters to attack your opponent and not his weapon.

A hypothesis I've been working on.

Profile PM Website

Kirk Lee Spencer

Quote

Posts: 820 Location: Texas

Sat 06 Jan, 2007 10:53 am

It is good to see this thread resurrected... But before I noticed, for just a moment, I thought Bjorn was back :\

It is interesting to me to see several threads on the Flamberge blade because, Lord willing, my next sword will have such a blade.

ks

Attachment: 93.82 KB

Profile PM

Glen A Cleeton

Quote

Posts: 1,978 Location: Nipmuc USA

Sat 06 Jan, 2007 3:50 pm

The way I see it, scallops or waves would be benifical to controlling another blade, or sliding down a pike haft to get at the users hands and the user themselves. After all, the end game is the other guy, not their weapon. Beat aside the pike and take out the soldier.

Whether they could cut the pole or no, it seems unlikely the pikeman would just stand there and not try to poke or whack you again.

As to the straight blades with the scalloped type geometery, there had been thought put forth (on one board or another) that it was, at the very least, a way to lighten a long blade. In other words, provide a rigid blade with less mass. It would be interesting to measure thickness and distal on a mess of biggies.

Cheers

GC

Cheers

Profile PM

Jean Henri Chandler

Quote

Posts: 1,420 Location: New Orleans

Sat 06 Jan, 2007 7:33 pm

Quote:

Sounds impressive - how thick was the pole? I guess the kind of wood used would be an important variable, but one of those Landsknecht zweihanders might be able to wack a pike with a lot more impact than the Constable, just due to sheer size.

The pole was pretty thick, at least 2". The wood wasn't anything special though, like whatever they used to make your larger mop handles in the old days. I'm not sure what kind of wood was used in pike-hafts? I imagine something like ash maybe?

If I can figure out where to get another great big pole like that I'll be glad to repeat the experiment and film it. We just did it that day at the end of a lot of test-cutting kind of on the spur of the moment (we had run out of things to cut and saw the pole, and came up with that idea...)

That Albion Constable, incidentally, though light sharply tapering and obviously designed for the thrust (being an Oakeshott XVa) is an amazingly good little cutter. I can cut tatami mats and thick cardboard tubes easily, let alone stuff like soda bottles and the like. I even cut a (supermarket) chicken in half with one stroke one time.

Jean

Profile PM

Jean Henri Chandler

Quote

Posts: 1,420 Location: New Orleans

Sat 06 Jan, 2007 7:35 pm

Glen A Cleeton wrote:

The way I see it, scallops or waves would be benifical to controlling another blade, or sliding down a pike haft to get at the users hands and the user themselves. After all, the end game is the other guy, not their weapon. Beat aside the pike and take out the soldier.

Whether they could cut the pole or no, it seems unlikely the pikeman would just stand there and not try to poke or whack you again.

As to the straight blades with the scalloped type geometery, there had been thought put forth (on one board or another) that it was, at the very least, a way to lighten a long blade. In other words, provide a rigid blade with less mass. It would be interesting to measure thickness and distal on a mess of biggies.

Cheers

GC

Cheers

Somebody should do a cutting test with a wave-bladed sword, and an equivalent as possible strait sword, and compare cutting, draw-cutting, cutting of wooden poles, etc.

Personally I'm convinced it's for draw-cutting, like a serrated kitchen knife.

J

Profile PM

Jean Thibodeau

Quote

Posts: 8,310 Location: Montreal,Quebec,Canada

Sat 06 Jan, 2007 8:08 pm

Jean Henri Chandler wrote:

Personally I'm convinced it's for draw-cutting, like a serrated kitchen knife.

J

I tend to agree with that as I have many Spyderco blades and the serrations are very aggressive in cutting action.

My Spydercos are all hair popping sharp so that would prove little but some of my butter knife dull steak knives still cut very well with their serrated blades.

Do wavy blade cut much better ? It guess if a strait blade can cut one in half easily a blade capable of doing it twice as easily won't make a lot of difference in a practical sense i.e. if 100% effective multiplying this by 2X to 200% is of debatable use.

On the other hand even a dull serrated blade should be a lot more effective with a draw cut with minimum effort.

I would be surprised that waves make no difference but they sure look " mean " and the psychological warfare effect of
" scary weapons " shouldn't be underestimated. :eek: Oh, and they have good aesthetics. :cool:

Profile PM

Jean Henri Chandler

Quote

Posts: 1,420 Location: New Orleans

Sat 06 Jan, 2007 8:31 pm

Jean Thibodeau wrote:

On the other hand even a dull serrated blade should be a lot more effective with a draw cut with minimum effort.

Exactly and if you look at the type of swords which typically had these 'wave' blades, at least in Europe, it's most commonly rapiers and zweihanders, both weapons which are succeptible to being grabbed by the opponent in a fight, and are clumsy in a clinch. Grabbing the opponents blade is a tactic in nearly every period fencing manual I have seen on rapiers.

I would be surprised that waves make no difference but they sure look " mean " and the psychological warfare effect of
" scary weapons " shouldn't be underestimated. :eek: Oh, and they have good aesthetics. :cool:[/quote]

Yes I would be surprised to, especially since they seem to have made so many of them, there are tons of surviving zweihanders with wavey blades in particular in muesums, castles, and auction houses all over the world. I can't remember how many I've seen. They almost seem more common than the non wavey ones.

One thing I have learned since I really started studying what you might call spathology; none of the parts of a sword was made in vain. Every component seems to have a specific purpose.

Thats why fantasy swords don't look right to me any more. All those wings and spikes, there is either no purpose to them or they are actually counterproductive. The functional elegance of the real thing is so much more appealing to me now.

J

Profile PM