Today's update:
[ Linked Image ]
Eric McHugh Bearded Axe
A hands-on review by Bill Grandy
[ Linked Image ]
Hanwei/CAS Iberia Mammen Axe
A hands-on review by Alexi Goranov
[ Linked Image ]
Arms & Armor Nordland Axe Prototype
A hands-on review by Joseph Fults
As always, you can see our Complete History of Updates listed right from our home page.
| Considering all of this week's latest additions, please rate the quality of our efforts. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Total Votes : 54 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
With this group, we welcome another new author: Joe Fults. Thanks, Joe!
Looking good. Though it means I have to keep waiting for a Kingmaker review for that much longer...
| William Knight wrote: |
| Looking good. Though it means I have to keep waiting for a Kingmaker review for that much longer... |
Patience, dear friend. Good things come to those who wait. :) In this case, you'll have to wait a little bit longer, since as far as I know, the reviewer we have lined up hasn't even received theirs yet.
| Chad Arnow wrote: |
| With this group, we welcome another new author: Joe Fults. Thanks, Joe! |
Thanks.
| Joe Fults wrote: |
|
Thanks. |
Right back at you. :) Working with you was a pleasure. I look forward to doing it again.
We're indebted to all our authors, old and new, for helping keep the content flowing here. :) The 118 articles/wallpapers, 169 reviews, 219 collection gallery pages, and all the as-yet-unpublished works in progress are the work of only 54 authors. We're always looking for more collaborators, too, so we can keep up with our aggressive publication schedule while continuing to add variety to our offerings.
| William Knight wrote: |
| Looking good. Though it means I have to keep waiting for a Kingmaker review for that much longer... |
Most makers aren't really that good about sending us review samples. I don't remember the last one we got from Albion. That means we have to rely on customers for review samples. If you guys miss timely reviews, contact the manufacturers of these items and harrass them into being more active about getting samples out. :D :p :D :p
(I'm sort of teasing here. I'm going to get slammed for this one...)
| Nathan Robinson wrote: | ||
Most makers aren't really that good about sending us review samples. I don't remember the last one we got from Albion. That means we have to rely on customers for review samples. If you guys miss timely reviews, contact the manufacturers of these items and harrass them into being more active about getting samples out. :D :p :D :p (I'm sort of teasing here. I'm going to get slammed for this one...) |
Well. it's actually a very good marketing strategy having one's product reviewed on this site: For one thing the quality of the photography seen here has often convinced me to BUY a sword that left me cold when just based on the maker's site pics.
Not that some of the maker's pics are bad quality: Only that the review pics are usually better in quality and also in the variety of views and angles of the product.
And that is cheap marketing if the only cost is shipping ! And the product get returned, RIGHT :p ( Unless the reviewer likes it to much and actually buys it. :p )
| Jean Thibodeau wrote: | ||||
Well. it's actually a very good marketing strategy having one's product reviewed on this site: For one thing the quality of the photography seen here has often convinced me to BUY a sword that left me cold when just based on the maker's site pics. Not that some of the maker's pics are bad quality: Only that the review pics are usually better in quality and also in the variety of views and angles of the product. And that is cheap marketing if the only cost is shipping ! And the product get returned, RIGHT :p ( Unless the reviewer likes it to much and actually buys it. :p ) |
I think the industry really does have a stake in the success of sites like myArmoury. Hopefully they offer some $upport to this site!
| Jean Thibodeau wrote: |
| ... And that is cheap marketing if the only cost is shipping ! And the product get returned, RIGHT :p ( Unless the reviewer likes it to much and actually buys it. :p ) |
Getting the reviewers to buy the pieces - yet another marketing strategy!! :D I'll bet if I had one of those Kingmaker's for review, it would be awfully hard to pry it out of my hands afterwards!
I love this set of updates! The axe reviews are great! I can't wait until the nordland axe comes out in final production.
Joe, Congrats on your first review, and thanks alot. Your review actually convinced me that I NEED the nordland axe. I hope we get to see more from you!
Keep up the great work everyone, we really appreciate it!
-James
Joe, Congrats on your first review, and thanks alot. Your review actually convinced me that I NEED the nordland axe. I hope we get to see more from you!
Keep up the great work everyone, we really appreciate it!
-James
| J. Bedell wrote: |
|
Joe, Congrats on your first review, and thanks alot. Your review actually convinced me that I NEED the nordland axe. I hope we get to see more from you! |
Interestingly enough, this was actually the third review Joe's written, but the first one published. Just the vagaries of our publication schedule. Look for more from Joe in the near future. :)
Thanks for the interesting reviews, gents, and another congratulations to Joe on his first review. Now, I know I need a proper axe!
Hi,
Great Axe update, the only thing I'd change is mixing it up between northern euro axes with other areas of Europe.
Great Axe update, the only thing I'd change is mixing it up between northern euro axes with other areas of Europe.
| Allen G. wrote: |
| Hi, Great Axe update, the only thing I'd change is mixing it up between northern euro axes with other areas of Europe. |
We can only review what we have available to review... If you guys like what we're doing, then I'd suggest to all our members that they contact the manufacturers and makers and request that they send us review samples. Maybe prodding from potential customers can lead to some success on this front. ;)
Hey it's worth a try.. next time I see something i'd really like a review on I'll shoot them an email about myArmoury. I'm surprised Albion doesn't send lots of samples since they have all your reviews linked on their site...
| Nathan Robinson wrote: |
|
We can only review what we have available to review... If you guys like what we're doing, then I'd suggest to all our members that they contact the manufacturers and makers and request that they send us review samples. Maybe prodding from potential customers can lead to some success on this front. ;) |
Don't forget the possibility of borrowing some items from people who are not quite motivated enough to do the review themselves. I am reasonably sure that there are opportunities to get a closer look at the items that are already in the hands of individual collectors, rather than relying on the maker to provide examples directly to the reviewers.
| Steve Fabert wrote: |
| Don't forget the possibility of borrowing some items from people who are not quite motivated enough to do the review themselves. I am reasonably sure that there are opportunities to get a closer look at the items that are already in the hands of individual collectors, rather than relying on the maker to provide examples directly to the reviewers. |
We don't forget that. In fact, most of our recent reviews have come from this. We've been relying on the membership for a long time.
I've had a question on my mind about the CASI axe. Since it hasn't been mentioned, I'll ask it here.
What's the liklihood that CAS Iberia/Hanwei mounted the axe head upside down on the shaft? It looks upside down to me.The way it's mounted ends up with a very weird edge angle. Not having ever handled this axe, I'm operating in a cloud of guesses. Having said that, however, it sure looks like the edge angle would make cutting less than ideal.
Thoughts?
[ Linked Image ]
Hanwei/CAS Iberia Mammen Axe
A hands-on review by Alexi Goranov
What's the liklihood that CAS Iberia/Hanwei mounted the axe head upside down on the shaft? It looks upside down to me.The way it's mounted ends up with a very weird edge angle. Not having ever handled this axe, I'm operating in a cloud of guesses. Having said that, however, it sure looks like the edge angle would make cutting less than ideal.
Thoughts?
[ Linked Image ]
Hanwei/CAS Iberia Mammen Axe
A hands-on review by Alexi Goranov
| Nathan Robinson wrote: |
| I've had a question on my mind about the CASI axe. Since it hasn't been mentioned, I'll ask it here.
What's the liklihood that CAS Iberia/Hanwei mounted the axe head upside down on the shaft? It looks upside down to me.The way it's mounted ends up with a very weird edge angle. Not having ever handled this axe, I'm operating in a cloud of guesses. Having said that, however, it sure looks like the edge angle would make cutting less than ideal. Thoughts? |
The original has a much more pronounced slant of the blade downward towards the haft. I looked very hard at the designs on the original and the reproduction and the orientation of the CAS one seems right (judging by the patterns on the blade). The problem is that the axe shape is a bit off on the reproduction so it is not a very easy comparison. Since the edge of the repro is virtually parallel to the haft, it seems to make little difference how they mounted it. The only peculiar part is the pronounced upper edge point. I reminds me a bit of a bearded axe mounted upwards.
I have not cut with mine but it seems that it will cut just fine, and the edge aligns well with the target when I simulate a cut in a slow motion exercise.
Alexi
Page 1 of 2
You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum