Go to page 1, 2  Next

Poll: Favorite Oakeshott type?
I've been wondering with the recent polls, What is your favorite Oakeshott type? It would be best to narrow it down to one or 2 of your favorite type. (subtypes included!). You can choose a type or just a subtype.

My favorites are XVIa and XVIIIb. I love cut and thrust design!

I'll try and tally it all up in the end...
hhhhmmmmm..... difficult. Usually I say: the right tool for the right job.

However, just generally speaking.....

Type XII/XIIa and XVI/XVIa

The XII because of it's classic line, it's why I ordered an Albion Knight. And the XVI because it's such a general purpose sword, IMO.
Yep, type XVIa because it seems like it can do it all, plus it has a fuller. I also like type XIII and XIIIa for the brutal single-mindedness of their design.
Type XIX ----- also XVIIIb ------ and XIIa


 Attachment: 19.8 KB
condottierej.jpg
Albion Condottiere XIX
XVIII&XVIII A-C.
Thomas Hoogendam wrote:
hhhhmmmmm..... difficult. Usually I say: the right tool for the right job.


I agree, but if I have to narrow it down then it'll be XIII/XIIIa and XVIa
Definitely the XVIIIb or XVIIIe types for me.
Now this is a tough one. :\ I have to agree with the "right tool for the right job" idea. It's not so much a matter of personal taste as it is functionality. But if I had to pick I'd go with something from the type XVIII family. Cutting and thrusting at its finest.:D
Re: Poll: Favorite Oakeshott type?
Michael F. wrote:
I've been wondering with the recent polls, What is your favorite Oakeshott type? It would be best to narrow it down to one or 2 of your favorite type. (subtypes included!). You can choose a type or just a subtype.


This is a very difficult question...

For single-handers, I find XI's to be beautiful and fascinating. XIII would be a close second.

For longswords, I find it hard to beat XVIII sub-types, though some XVIa's have also attracted my eyes...

For true two-handers, I think the Danes got a great idea-- XVIIIe rocks. Though XX's can be pretty cool, too...
Types XVIII and XVIIIe for me.

Jeff Ross
Type XVa for me the long versions...

Martin
Personally I favor the type XII's and the type XVII's.
Like the rest of us, I don't have one particular favorite. For single-hand swords, I prefer Type XII (Albion's Knight). For longswords, it'll have to be either Type XVa or XVIIIa (Arms&Armor's Black Prince or Schloss Erbach). -Ted
Re: Poll: Favorite Oakeshott type?
Jeremiah Swanger wrote:
Michael F. wrote:
I've been wondering with the recent polls, What is your favorite Oakeshott type? It would be best to narrow it down to one or 2 of your favorite type. (subtypes included!). You can choose a type or just a subtype.


This is a very difficult question...

Easy question for me to answer - no preference. Each type came to be as a result of particular needs, and I find something to admire in each of the forms.
Oakshotte types XVII and XVIIIb. I have the Albion Crecy Grete ( not really a clean XVII type, but the closest available on the cheap at the time I ordered it) and a Munich on Order.
I like them all, but if I had to choose one it would be the Type X. No big surprise there. :lol:
X or XII for single-handers.

XIIa or XIIIa for the big guys.

I like the earlier stuff.
Type XII and XVIa.

I own a Laird, and one day I'll buy a Crecy (try not to think about it...)

David
It´s not so much how the look... They all look fine, it´s what you can do with a XVa ;9
I have a type XVIa on order and I'm negotating a XIIIa. As many have stated, I like the all-purpose nature of the XVIa. I also like the brutish nature of the minimal profile taper blade of the XIIIa.
Go to page 1, 2  Next

Page 1 of 2

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum