So my wife has strongly hinted that I might be getting either the Pedite or the Trajan Pompeii Gladius for Christmas, and it's dawned on me that whenever I see someone post their Albion swords I never hear about their scabbards. Can someone verify if Albion swords come with scabbards or not?

Albion site listed couple scabbard makers, their swords don't come with a scabbard.
http://www.albion-swords.com/swords/scabbards/scabbards.htm

Unfortunately no. Albion used to offer a service to make scabbards, but it was quite costly unless you got the most basic type; I think that artisan has left their employment though so it's not an option any longer.

There are several excellent makers who can make many scabbards for you . Sometimes without you having to send in the sword. Christian Fletcher and Brian Kunz are probably the biggest names out there. Russ Ellis of Tritonworks may also be available. Steve Huerta (I don't know if he has a website but he has a Facebook page, Steve Huerta Custom Leatherworks or some such) does good work as well though he's just getting started. JE Sarge used to make them, but unfortunately he's out of business right now due to other obligations. If you're UK or Europe based, Leo Todeschini also does Albion scabbards.

You can buy the Albion sword through Christian Fletcher, and he will make the scabbard for you - so you can consolidate. The scabbards are not inexpensive. http://www.christianfletcher.com/

Right from Albion? No. And (just me) - I'm glad they do NOT.

There are a LOAD of sword makers that offer scabbards with their offerings. For the most part? Those scabbards are garbage. Yes - they will hold a sword.... probably SEVERAL swords, of totally different proportions.

Just me - but I would give Albion credit for making a really GOOD sword - and leaving the really GOOD scabbard to others that are very good at making scabbards - and not forcing you into buying a substandard paint stick, at extra cost, that you would likely toss out in the trash anyway.

All opinion - not gospel, I make my own scabbards.... and have accumulated a LOT of OEM "paint stick junk" that I would hate to see others get stuck with :).

Example core, WIP - poplar, not a paint stick, total cost about $28 in raw materials. Labor? WHAT labor? :).
[ Linked Image ]

[ Linked Image ]

Word on the grapevine is that Albion's scabbard shop is slowly opening back up for business. Last I heard, they were putting up ready-to-ship scabbards as the became available, but not taking direct commissions as of yet. It might be worth a phone call to see where they are currently at on scabbard work to be sure.

Regardless of who makes a scabbard, I think the key to a good scabbard is to do your research and be very, very detailed with your specs. Just because someone is a skilled and experienced scabbard maker doesn't mean that they will make you a proper period scabbard.

Dean's sword got a nice scabbard. Funny thing is why would a company like Albion make swords without scabbards.

Harry is dead-on here. Professional scabbard makers do not necessarily know the subtle nuances of how scabbards changed in style over a particular century, or the subtle variations based upon geographic regions. Some, like our own Maciej Kopciuch, spend time closely studying period art before creating a scabbard for a commission, but not all do. The other challenge is that a scabbard maker ultimately need to do what the customer wants, so if a customer wants a metal chape on their late 11th/early 12th century sword, the customer gets one.

I suspect a fair number of people (not necessarily scabbard makers, but laymen) have seen Peter Johnsson’s guide on making a scabbard and think “Great-now I know how to make an authentic medieval scabbard!” The reality, of course, is that Peter’s guide is an excellent guide for one particular style of scabbard, most appropriate as general representation for part of the 13th century. Yet the styles of suspension, strapping, incised lines, the presence or absence of chapes (and their shape) and many other factors affect how appropriate a particular scabbard is for a particular period and region. It’s easy, however, to think “A scabbard is a scabbard is a scabbard”--just the way many people would look at Oakeshott Type X, Xa, XI, XIa, XII, and XIIIb swords and think “They’re all the same!” It’s noticing nuance and detail that is crucial for the connoisseur of historically accurate swords, and of historically accurate scabbards, too.

As noted, for Albion to do a scabbard & suspension in line with the accuracy and quality of their swords, you would be looking at double the time and nearly double the price, unless you are happy with a Windlass-style scabbard (only loosely "fitted", ahistorical and bland). The reasons for this is that: every sword is just a little different, and a scabbard could not be made until the sword is finished; each scabbard would have to be finished entirely by hand, meaning significant labor cost (assuming people want to get paid for what they do...); and, to be economically viable, pricing would have to include some allowance for mistakes and starting over - humans are not infallible, chisels occasionally slip, materials sometimes have unseen defects, etc.

As one that has had scabbards made by a top-notch craftsman, but one that used their own sword as stand-in, rather than me sending my actual sword, I would also counsel against "off the shelf", no matter how good the craftsman is. In my case, I received four top-notch scabbards and suspensions; unfortunately, only one of them fit "right" - one was a bit loose, and two a bit tight. I can make certain modifications to make the fit better, but it will never be completely "right". This isn't due to poor workmanship by the maker, but due to slight variances even in "production" swords. Even though each Albion starts with a billet standard to each blade (as I understand it - please correct me if I'm wrong), each blade is still ground by an individual human being, by hand, and not all laser or water cut by a CNC machine that will theoretically do everything exactly the same way, to the micrometer, each and every time. A half-millimeter of difference between my Albion and the scabbard maker's Albion of the same design will mean that my sword fits differently than the maker's sword, and will mean I've spent several hundred dollars for something that isn't quite right. Nobody made an error in production - I simply made an error in budgeting and judgement. I should have budgeted the purchase of a hard-case for shipping, and for the shipping itself, and sent my sword to the maker, who could then fit the scabbard precisely to my sword. This is likely to add 10% to 25% to the cost (depending upon where you send it) but will result in as perfect a fit has human hands can render. If the case is big enough, maybe you can cut the per-unit cost by shipping multiple swords, although you might then get into "oversize package" costs that make the economics less favorable.

Bottom line - a maker such as Albion will likely never make scabbards a "standard" feature of every sword. And they shouldn't - scabbards & suspensions are as much about decoration and personal style as they are about storage and carry. If they issued a scabbard with every sword, for it to be even minimally economical, it would have to be a simple leather sheath, unadorned. While this would be reasonable for storage purposes, it wouldn't really provide the functional and historic product that most people would actually want. This is something A&A actually offers - I have a second-hand Durer with their simple leather scabbard - works fine for storage, and I can actually fit it into a pre-made suspension and frog, but it isn't really very historical from a "carry" perspective - I'd have to do research to determine how often such sheaths were used in practice for storage and transport, since it seems a decent idea. However, if I order a new sword from them and don't have the funds or inclination to have a custom scabbard made immediately, then I would likely spring for the extra ~$100 (usually a little less, as I recall), and have the simple "storage" scabbard shipped with.

I think I ended up on a soap box and chasing a few tangents - sorry about that - but I hope my points and my reasons for them came through.

FYI Albion DOES make scabbards. Their scabbard maker is Buck Bates. I own 4 and have another in the making. They're quite nice and a value at the price in my opinion even though they're ready made and not custom to your order (though I'm sure if you contacted Mike at Albion he'd work something out with you and Buck). Since Albion has all swords in house there is no need to ship yours off to be fit perfectly too.

You can see them here:

http://albion-swords.com/swords/scabbards/Buck%20Scabbards.htm