Looks like the Fischer auction house is doing more arms and armor items this go around. Some nice pieces in this group.
Fischer Auction catalog
Best
Craig
Thanks for the link! I haven't put my due diligence in to find stuff like this lately. There's some great things to see there.
very nice indeed, off to register, thanks for that!
There's a lot of wonderful things in there. I'll have to spend more time looking through all of it. One thing caught my eye immediately - this classic shape from around 1400. I'm not sure about the pommel inset - it looks herbaceous.
Attachment: 76.09 KB
Attachment: 76.09 KB
It speaks to me too, Patrick.
But my very favourite is this one:
Attachment: 122.48 KB
But my very favourite is this one:
Attachment: 122.48 KB
Two more faves...........
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
Nice clean lines on this one.
[ Linked Image ]
Here's an interesting one, an actual training sword.
[ Linked Image ]
Someone here digs these things. ;)
[ Linked Image ]
Lots of very cool stuff there. I saved quite a few of the photos as I can see several candidates for custom projects.
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
Nice clean lines on this one.
[ Linked Image ]
Here's an interesting one, an actual training sword.
[ Linked Image ]
Someone here digs these things. ;)
[ Linked Image ]
Lots of very cool stuff there. I saved quite a few of the photos as I can see several candidates for custom projects.
Craig,
Great stuff !
Thanks !
Tim Mathews
Great stuff !
Thanks !
Tim Mathews
Some great items - has anyone ever participated in one of these auctions? (or, better yet, won something?) I'd be curious to hear what the whole process is like.
Original pieces always seem to have more elegant proportions and styling than reproductions.
Whether that's true or not-I don't know. But, few modern reproductions look as ... real.
Whether that's true or not-I don't know. But, few modern reproductions look as ... real.
Roger,
If I am not mistaken, "Stile um 1400" is "in the style of 1400". I think it's a (more) modern reproduction trying to look like an earlier sword.
If I am not mistaken, "Stile um 1400" is "in the style of 1400". I think it's a (more) modern reproduction trying to look like an earlier sword.
Many pieces in that auction are in the style of originals, described as such or not.
Is this actually real (antique)?
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
A rough translation of the text, with the help of Google Translate, plus a few modifications that I made.
Knight figure, 12 Century composite. Consisting of a nasal helmet, probably French: Bell with distinct midrib, inside rep, nasal re-screwed.. Feed holes. Circumferentially engraved decor: A-shaped sign with lily. Coat of mail, hauberk, covering the entire body: hood, shirt with long sleeves and gloves. Shirt with front slit, round fringe. Lower leg chausses and leather shoes. Ring outside diameter 11 mm, with rivet heads. At the neck brass ring with Gothic minuscule (probably the name of the Sarwürkers). Sword (L 94.5 cm), with belt and scabbard new: corr iron. and purified. Mushroom pommel straight, rounded quillons, grip covered in leather. Double-edged blade, double hollow ground center [I think it actually means a fuller on both sides] up to about 5 cm above point (type XI by Oakeshott). Knights rest.
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
A rough translation of the text, with the help of Google Translate, plus a few modifications that I made.
Knight figure, 12 Century composite. Consisting of a nasal helmet, probably French: Bell with distinct midrib, inside rep, nasal re-screwed.. Feed holes. Circumferentially engraved decor: A-shaped sign with lily. Coat of mail, hauberk, covering the entire body: hood, shirt with long sleeves and gloves. Shirt with front slit, round fringe. Lower leg chausses and leather shoes. Ring outside diameter 11 mm, with rivet heads. At the neck brass ring with Gothic minuscule (probably the name of the Sarwürkers). Sword (L 94.5 cm), with belt and scabbard new: corr iron. and purified. Mushroom pommel straight, rounded quillons, grip covered in leather. Double-edged blade, double hollow ground center [I think it actually means a fuller on both sides] up to about 5 cm above point (type XI by Oakeshott). Knights rest.
The mail, to me, looks more like what I would expect of 15th century mail. I have never seen a surviving grip on a 12th century sword before, which makes me wonder if this sword might be a modern fake, or, at the very least, the grip has been redone in more recent times. The helmet is also in extremely good condition, which likewise makes me wonder about its actual age.
I realize that the scabbard, shoes, and the padding under the mail are all modern.
I realize that the scabbard, shoes, and the padding under the mail are all modern.
The shirt (sans mittens) seems likely to be 15th century German, with its gothic miniscule signet ring at the neck, all-riveted construction, "pent-roof" riveted area, and clear wedge riveting on the overturned brass rings at the neck. The coif actually seems to be older with it's demi-riveted construction, but may have been chopped up from something. It might be Persian, but it's hard to say for sure without a look at the back. How much modification has been done to get the ensemble to look like something from the late 12th century is difficult to say without more photographs or a detailed examination.
i could only get through the first 10 pages - so much stuff
i think was my favorite as i was browsing through the pages
Attachment: 87.3 KB
i think was my favorite as i was browsing through the pages
Attachment: 87.3 KB
Whoops, that Roman Hagenau helmet (Item #2) is a Deepeeka Coolus E after an acid bath.
http://www.deepeeka.in/index.php?route=Coolus...ayout=grid
Shoot, I sold mine for a little less than that...
I'm VERY suspicious of the Phrygian helmet, Item #1, but it doesn't quite match the photo on the Deepeeka site. The patina is too even, the condition too good overall.
Caveat Emptor, kids!
Matthew
Edit: Re-edit: Thought I had the Thracian helmet at Kult of Athena, but it's not an exact match:
http://www.kultofathena.com/product.asp?item=...acian+Helm
http://www.deepeeka.in/index.php?route=Coolus...ayout=grid
Shoot, I sold mine for a little less than that...
I'm VERY suspicious of the Phrygian helmet, Item #1, but it doesn't quite match the photo on the Deepeeka site. The patina is too even, the condition too good overall.
Caveat Emptor, kids!
Matthew
Edit: Re-edit: Thought I had the Thracian helmet at Kult of Athena, but it's not an exact match:
http://www.kultofathena.com/product.asp?item=...acian+Helm
Fantastic link Craig!!! Thanks for posting.
Craig Peters wrote: |
Roger,
If I am not mistaken, "Stile um 1400" is "in the style of 1400". I think it's a (more) modern reproduction trying to look like an earlier sword. |
Actually (if you can trust the translation),the blurb translates as:
sword, in the French style around 1400. Iron vessel, wheel knob with silver insert, Vernietknäufchen. Slightly curved quillons ortwärts. Leathered grip. Double-edged blade rhombic, brand. Plate 31 CHF 2'000 / 4'000 EUR 1'667 / 3'333 USD 2'222 / 4'444
If it was a repro, would they have rusted it up to make it look like an antique? That seems deceptive. Swords in other places like Hermann Historica that are titled sword in the style of 1400 always look new and pristine. Also, the auction price of up to $4,444.00 seems kind of high for a reproduction.
Last edited by Roger Hooper on Wed 04 Sep, 2013 11:56 am; edited 1 time in total
Roger Hooper wrote: | ||
Actually (if you can trust the translation),the blurb translates as: sword, in the French style around 1400. Iron vessel, wheel knob with silver insert, Vernietknäufchen. Slightly curved quillons ortwärts. Leathered grip. Double-edged blade rhombic, brand. Plate 31 CHF 2'000 / 4'000 EUR 1'667 / 3'333 USD 2'222 / 4'444 If it was a repro, would they have rusted it up to make it look like an antique? That seems deceptive. Swords in other places like Hermann Historica that are titled sword in the style of 1400 always look new and pristine. |
Herman Historica tends to over-polish/over-restore their items, unfortunately. This is true for originals and later recreations. It's their thing because their audience/consumers tend to spend more on that.
Fischer is very fast and loose with their descriptions. That sword does not appear to be from circa 1400 to me.
Page 1 of 2
You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum