Just wondering how accurate this sword is. I am still searching for a "gothic" type sword for my Sigmund armour.

http://www.kultofathena.com/product.asp?item=...thic+Sword

On a scale of one to ten, maybe a three. If it is truly based on an original, I'd be interested in seeing the example this reproduction is modeled after.

Cheers

GC

So its a stinker. I'm open to examples that are correct. Any suggestions?

Well the Albion Regent comes to mind. ;)

http://www.myArmoury.com/review_alb_reg.html

Same pommel type, but crisp bevel lines and the blade is period accurate and all Albion swords where researched and designed by Peter Johnsson. In the Next Generation line the swords are typical of " type " but not based on a specific sword. In the Museum line they are as closely replicates of an actual period sword as it was when newly made. ( Some original swords are damaged or corroded enough, or show wear from use and multiple resharpenings that original dimensions have to be guessed at to some degree ).

There are other good makers out there like A&A and custom makers that are also very accurate in period design and some like Leo Todeschini also seem to give a period look to their swords and other weapons or kit. ( In period some irregularities of dimensions or finish didn't seem to bother them, even for high end weapons. Modern tastes are for greater perfection in symmetry and finish ).

http://www.todsstuff.co.uk/index.htm

The Eared Dagger ( Lower one ) was made by Leo for me as a custom order:
http://www.todsstuff.co.uk/knives-military/ea...knives.htm

Fabrice Cognot is also a maker who emphasizes period look and methods of making and tries to avoid a modern CNC machined look.

http://www.myArmoury.com/talk/viewtopic.php?t=25993

If looking at less expensive swords it's good to examine originals and the high end reproductions for style and authenticity and then chose those less expensive makers that seem to be closest to these.

Now if one can afford an Albion or another of the top production swords it usually a better choice as well as looking at custom makers with a good reputation for quality work.

I also own many of the less expensive swords by Del Tin and other medium priced and decent quality makers.

With some makers it's a question of being selective because some of their product line can be acceptable to very good and other's in their line not as much. Some can be good with a little DIY upgrades like replacing chunky or ugly grip furniture, refinishing to hide modern and machine looking grind lines or turning a mirror polished finish into a more period appropriate satin finish. ( This last partly a question of personal preferences ).

Hey Jean, you mentioned Del Tin. How about this one: http://www.kultofathena.com/product.asp?item=...Half+Sword

Would it be ok for Sigmund armor?

I'm far from the most knowledgeable or experienced around here, but I have bought two swords in the $300 price range in the last 14 months. One was a DSA. The other was at least twice the sword as the DSA, made by Legacy Arms Gen 2. I'm not recommending that you buy from any particular manufacturer, but at the appox. $300 price point there are significantly better choices than DSA (in my humble opinion).

There are so many "choices". I currently own this: http://www.arms-n-armor.com/sword194.html and I really like it. I was thinking of having Sonny at Valiant redo the grip in a 1/2 wire wrap. He already did a nice wood core scabbard for it in black leather & simple chape. I'm just not sure if it would pass with my armor. i am not looking for 100% match to the armor but would like it close. Any thoughts on that combination?

Glen, thanks for posting the pics. I was looking at the DSA stuff only due to looking at items on KOA. I am totally unfamiliar with DSA stuff.
I see you have a Del Tin....just simply sell me yours cheap ;) That would make it much ezer for me. I am still very new so Jean is right...I kinda limited my self. I have found armor is not as forgiving as weapons in time period/era use. I am not really going to do anything with the items....just play in them at ren. fests/living history etc. but I dont want junk. I do want to look relatively period though. Thanks for the other ideas on the swords. I Still may get the partial wire wrap done on the AA I have.
As a side note, if anyone has a sword type that I'm looking for that they want to sell...by all means let me know.

Does it have to be specifically late 15th-century German? If not, I don't see why a sufficiently generic sword like the Hanwei Tinker Bastard wouldn't fit the bill:

http://www.kultofathena.com/product.asp?item=...tard+Sword

My opinion is quite limited, I only own two swords. One of them however is a DSA. Perhaps they're known for durability, but they are known to me for shabbiness. I believe there are better choices, even at the same price point. You might like the picture, but far less likely that you like the sword once its in your hands. At least that was my experience.

How about this late 15th C sword, EP45 from Arma Bohemia in the Czech Republic? I don't have personal experience with them, but Arma Bohemia has a good reputation on this website.

---

 Attachment: 134.04 KB

EP45

 Attachment: 127.27 KB

EP45