Good to hear they are being very quick about the fixes :) . Now if they can just get the edges right on the rest of their euro lines as well hehe.
I hope by the time I order mine this spring, I will be fortunate enough to get one with good edges. Getting a belt for it through CF, but it will be next fall before I do any further upgrades (the guard I want seems as if it will need a scabbard to go with it!
M.
M.
Yeah, as far as I know the current shipment is sold out so by next fall the new edge ought to be worked out. I'd cut with mine and it worked OK, but I sharpened it before cutting yesterday and it definitely was a bit easier. When I examined it before sharpening yesterday there was a distinct bur on the edge, and this might tend to fold over during cutting making the sword seem duller than it actually is. This can be removed by slicing 7-8 ounce leather or with a buffer and the sword should perform better. Unfortunately most people don't have lots of scraps of heavy leather lying around, or a buffer either for that matter... Anyway if I am understanding them right the new sharpening method ought to take care of that as well.
So is this new edge process going to be applied to all the line up or just your line only? Oh and will the fixed EMS and the viking sword be coming with the new edges?
| P. Cha wrote: |
| So is this new edge process going to be applied to all the line up or just your line only? Oh and will the fixed EMS and the viking sword be coming with the new edges? |
As far as I know just to my line, and I certainly hope so!
Am I really the only one wondering how a paper shaving edge can be terrible for cutting?
| Michael Edelson wrote: |
| Am I really the only one wondering how a paper shaving edge can be terrible for cutting? |
Because the angle is so agressive that as you slice through a target like a bottle or mat, the target shears are a very high angle. This means that it take more force to cut through the target because you need to displace more mass because the angle is so steep. Appleseed edges displaces less mass so it cuts targets better. I can explain this with pictures if anyone needs me to :) .
Actually an appleseed edge may or may not displace more material. The relevant factors here are the thickness of the edge prior to sharpening and the angle of the edge after sharpening. If all other factors are equal in absolute terms an appleseed edge ought to cut better than a beveled edge but if both are done correctly either edge will work well enough that a human can't tell the difference.
The relevance of this to the present discussion of course is that the edge on this sword was NOT done correctly and that ought to fixed in future production.
The relevance of this to the present discussion of course is that the edge on this sword was NOT done correctly and that ought to fixed in future production.
| Michael Pearce wrote: |
| Actually an appleseed edge may or may not displace more material. The relevant factors here are the thickness of the edge prior to sharpening and the angle of the edge after sharpening. If all other factors are equal in absolute terms an appleseed edge ought to cut better than a beveled edge but if both are done correctly either edge will work well enough that a human can't tell the difference.
The relevance of this to the present discussion of course is that the edge on this sword was NOT done correctly and that ought to fixed in future production. |
True enough...but a bevel edge at the right angle generally isn't sharp enough to shave paper. A bevel edge that is at an angle that is sharp enough to shave paper runs into the displacement issue I mentioned :) . An appleseed edge can be made paper shaving sharp and still cut properly...which is what my sword now has. Along with a HT tough enough where the edge is fine after taking a 4 inch chuck out of a treated hardwood post that we are using as a stand. This makes me happy :) .
If it's not too much trouble, would you mind posting measurements for the diameter and thickness of the pommel?
Thanks! :)
Thanks! :)
| P. Cha wrote: |
| [ Along with a HT tough enough where the edge is fine after taking a 4 inch chuck out of a treated hardwood post that we are using as a stand. This makes me happy :) . |
This makes me happy too!
Page 2 of 2
You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum