Hi
I was wondering when the term morningstar was coined? Is it a period term or a later invention. Also, does it refer to all weapons with spiked balls or only to the flail variety? Is a knobbed head also a morningstar or must it feature spikes?
Hi Kenneth,
To the best of my knowledge the morgenstern ("morningstar" in English) is, properly speaking, a mace with a spiked head-- this is as opposed to the flail (therscol) which is commonly (and mistakenly) called a morningstar today.
I don't know how the morningstar got its name, but wouldn't be surprised if it had a somewhat humorous origin-- the same weapon was also called a "godendag" (meaning "good day! :D ).
Hope that helps,
David
To the best of my knowledge the morgenstern ("morningstar" in English) is, properly speaking, a mace with a spiked head-- this is as opposed to the flail (therscol) which is commonly (and mistakenly) called a morningstar today.
I don't know how the morningstar got its name, but wouldn't be surprised if it had a somewhat humorous origin-- the same weapon was also called a "godendag" (meaning "good day! :D ).
Hope that helps,
David
may or may not be connected to how it got its name, but morning star also means a planet that rises before the sun (usually venus)
perhaps the spiked head of the mace resembled a star. Thats just a stab in the dark though
perhaps the spiked head of the mace resembled a star. Thats just a stab in the dark though
David McElrea wrote: |
Hi Kenneth,
To the best of my knowledge the morgenstern ("morningstar" in English) is, properly speaking, a mace with a spiked head-- this is as opposed to the flail (therscol) which is commonly (and mistakenly) called a morningstar today. I don't know how the morningstar got its name, but wouldn't be surprised if it had a somewhat humorous origin-- the same weapon was also called a "godendag" (meaning "good day! :D ). Hope that helps, David |
David
I may be way off here and this link may have ben discredited, but it suggests that a godendag or goedendag is quite different from a morningstar.
http://www.liebaart.org/goeden_e.htm
I came across it a little while back in a spin-off from a similar discussion and I've been trying to get hold of the parts to try and make one (a bucket spike off a bobcat loader is the current favourite for the pointy end).
Geoff
Hi Geoff,
Thanks for the correction-- I hadn't realised there was such a weapon as the one shown on the link-- I had also assumed the godendag/goedendag was German. Flemish... hmm!
I appreciate it,
David
Thanks for the correction-- I hadn't realised there was such a weapon as the one shown on the link-- I had also assumed the godendag/goedendag was German. Flemish... hmm!
I appreciate it,
David
isn't it interesting how people in the middle ages gave such pleasant names to their spiked implements of painful death? "good day", "morning star", and "holy water sprinkler". somebody back then must have had a sense of humor :D
David McElrea wrote: |
Hi Geoff,
Thanks for the correction-- I hadn't realised there was such a weapon as the one shown on the link-- I had also assumed the godendag/goedendag was German. Flemish... hmm! I appreciate it, David |
Hi David
Well, I'm not sure it's a correction, just another opinion, but it seems to fairly well backed up. I, like you, have seen goedendags (or whatever the correct plural is) equated with morningstars and even with halberds. These ones put me in mind of upmarket digging sticks for breaking up hard ground. A lot of weapons seem to have had agricultural forebears.
Regards
Geoff
Dan Tucker wrote: |
isn't it interesting how people in the middle ages gave such pleasant names to their spiked implements of painful death? "good day", "morning star", and "holy water sprinkler". somebody back then must have had a sense of humor :D |
Perhaps the name is meant to give positive feelings by associating with something pleasant.
Dan Tucker wrote: |
isn't it interesting how people in the middle ages gave such pleasant names to their spiked implements of painful death? "good day", "morning star", and "holy water sprinkler". somebody back then must have had a sense of humor :D |
Hi Dan
I think black 'humorous' or more friendly sounding naming continues into more modern times (Chicago piano, Peacemaker [either one], Ronson, Stalin's banjo etc.). Other trades and professions have pet names for their equipment. Maybe soldiers need a laugh more than most.
And the famed Molotov Cocktail. :D As I understand, it was devised by the Finns as an anti-tank weapon when they were invaded by the Soviets (whose Foreign Minister was Mr. Molotov). It is a sardonic title, I think.
What about the "Arkansas Toothpick"?
Dan Tucker wrote: |
isn't it interesting how people in the middle ages gave such pleasant names to their spiked implements of painful death? "good day", "morning star", and "holy water sprinkler". somebody back then must have had a sense of humor :D |
Most definately. :lol:
Page 1 of 1
You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum