Is there any higher quality rapiers? I would like similar to the quality and price of Albion's Maestro line. I would also like to be able to spar with it.(No sharp tips and edges) Any good ones?
www.darkwoodarmory.com - especially if you want a rapier to spar with.
I highly recommend waiting for the Maestro if you want it primarily for sparring. A rapier's blade should be rigid and there aren't any good rigid blades out there.
| Greg Coffman wrote: |
| I highly recommend waiting for the Maestro if you want it primarily for sparring. A rapier's blade should be rigid and there aren't any good rigid blades out there. |
I disagree; there are good rapier blades out there. First, any of the A&A rapier blades will work fine, if you get them stock and want to spar with them, they are more likely to be too rigid than not rigid enough; second, Darkwood Armory bated rapier blades are plenty rigid; they definitely fall within the range of historical rapier blades as far is "whippiness". That is two I can think of offhand--but there are others. If you find a good manufacturer, they'll make them to your specification--just understand that you pay extra for custom work.
Additionally, rapier blades don't really need to be all that rigid to be accurate in their behavior. While you don't want them to be too "whippy" this is easily managed by a competent manufacturer and is more a matter of how the mass is distributed on the blade (i.e. how it is tapered) than by the absolute mass or thickness of the blade.
It is worth noting that even our ancestors didn't always use full-weight blades for practice and free-play. There are examples of "rapier foils" in museums--that is, rapiers with lighter quadrilateral practices blades which could seem rather light by our standards.
Steve
Thanks guys. I will defeintely look into A&A and Darkwood. They look to be excellent blades! Do you guys have any?
| Thomas G wrote: |
| Thanks guys. I will definitely look into A&A and Darkwood. They look to be excellent blades! Do you guys have any? |
We (i.e. the Of the Seven Hearts) have several. Here is a photo with several (but by no means all) that we own. Additionally, in this photo you can see a few A&A swords: the Gustav Vasa in the bottom row, and a Milanese Rapier with a full-length rapier blade mounted on it in the top row. Additionally, there are two originals, one is from around 1580 and the other from the early 1600s. Also, in the bottom row you can see part of a smallsword hilt, and Tom's custom A&A rapier, and a Del Tin rapier. All the rest in the photo are Darkwood (there are seven in this photo).
[ Linked Image ]
Additionally, these are all Darkwood rapiers, excepting only the center rapier in the bottom photo (which is the Del Tin):
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
[ Linked Image ]
Steve
Thank you Steve! Is the jump of price from Darkwood Armoury to Arms & Armor worth it?
| Thomas G wrote: |
| Thank you Steve! Is the jump of price from Darkwood Armoury to Arms & Armor worth it? |
Yes, I think it is. However, I don't think you have to buy an A&A to get a rapier you can be happy with. Additionally, you can easily customize a Darkwood so that it costs as much (or more) than the standard A&A (although you can also customize an A&A, with appropriate price adjustments). There are differences between the two, but which make you would prefer is a matter of experience and personal preference. If possible, handle weapons from both makers (the more recently made, the better--these guys are both getting better every year).
Note that I don't want anyone to believe that I have a problem with the upcoming Albion model. Based on everything I've seen by Albion, I would expect that it will be quite good. However, until I actually handle one, I won't be able to say one way or the other.
There are also other makers, but I just don't have much experience with them beyond handling weapons that belong to other people.
Steve
Where would one be able to handle these weapons?
| Thomas G wrote: |
| Where would one be able to handle these weapons? |
Darkwood rapiers are all over the WMA community--you pretty much can't go to an event without seeing them. Additionally, they are used by many in the SCA for rapier fighting. A&A swords are not as common, although you'll usually see a few at a historic fencing seminar.
Steve
Thank you Steve. I think when I have the money I am going to go with a Darkwood Armoury rapier. That is one of the rapiers the instructor of a class (Italian Rapier) I am going to take recommends.
And they are cheaper too. Eventually I will most likely get an A&A but not yet.
And they are cheaper too. Eventually I will most likely get an A&A but not yet.
| Thomas G wrote: |
| Thank you Steve. I think when I have the money I am going to go with a Darkwood Armoury rapier. That is one of the rapiers the instructor of a class (Italian Rapier) I am going to take recommends.
And they are cheaper too. Eventually I will most likely get an A&A but not yet. |
Where are you (i.e. your location)?
Steve
I am located near St. Louis MO
Page 1 of 1
You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum