Bronze on early medieval swords
Hello everyone,

I have found myself wondering iif early midieval swords (1050-1200) had pommels and or guards made of bronze. Are there examples of bronze brazil nut or tea cozy pommels? The examples I can think of have pommels of iron- and in one case the iron tea cozy was originally covered in gold. If there are historical examples of bronze hilted early medieval swords I think that it would be nice to see someone like Albion make a quality reproduction.

Thanks,
Jeremy
Re: Bronze on early medieval swords
Jeremy V. Krause wrote:
Hello everyone,

I have found myself wondering iif early midieval swords (1050-1200) had pommels and or guards made of bronze. Are there examples of bronze brazil nut or tea cozy pommels? The examples I can think of have pommels of iron- and in one case the iron tea cozy was originally covered in gold. If there are historical examples of bronze hilted early medieval swords I think that it would be nice to see someone like Albion make a quality reproduction.

Thanks,
Jeremy

They exist, but they are very rare, and usually brass (though not modern high zinc brass, but what's refered to as "latten"). There's one sword in the book "Swords of the Viking age" with bronze fittings, and I saw one sword in the Irish Museum in Dublin: http://1501bc.com/page/Umha_Aois_2006/20060627/06270030.jpg. However nearly all swords have iron fittings, and copper alloy inlays instead. There are however many reproductions that have bronze fittings, which aren't historically correct (just cheaper to produce).
Re: Bronze on early medieval swords
Jeroen Zuiderwijk wrote:
They exist, but they are very rare, and usually brass (though not modern high zinc brass, but what's refered to as "latten"). There's one sword in the book "Swords of the Viking age" with bronze fittings, and I saw one sword in the Irish Museum in Dublin: http://1501bc.com/page/Umha_Aois_2006/20060627/06270030.jpg. However nearly all swords have iron fittings, and copper alloy inlays instead. There are however many reproductions that have bronze fittings, which aren't historically correct (just cheaper to produce).


Usually brass (or an equivalent)? I've not heard that before. Most say that bronze was more common and more useable than brass. Any pictures of these brass-hilted swords?
Type XII.1 in Records of the Medieval Sword has a bronze pommel, though it may be a tad later than your date of 1200.

From what I can find (or not find actually), it doesn't seem to have been common. We know of bronze used before and after that period, so one could guess that it would have been used during that period, too, but there aren't many at all that show it.

I like the look of the cuprous metals and don't find it to be much harder to justify from an accuracy standpoint than using modern mild and tool steels. :)
The use of copper alloy fittings in the Viking age I think is probably more common than we might think. For some reason though complete examples are somewhat rare. There are a number of pommel caps that have been found in Anglo-Saxon and Anglo-Scandinavian context. Several years ago on ebay a very nice example of a bronze hilted viking age sword sold and it seemed very unique at the time to me. Once I started coming across the pommel caps it become clear something was going on since they are all very similar. One interesting thing that runs common with them is that stands out as different from most other pommel caps from the viking age is that the tang runs all the way through them and is peened.

A quick search on http://www.findsdatabase.org.uk will turn up several of these pommel caps.

Here are a couple though....
http://www.findsdatabase.org.uk/hms/pas_obj.p...6D6E201E47

http://www.findsdatabase.org.uk/hms/pas_obj.p...7F9E7015B9

http://www.findsdatabase.org.uk/hms/pas_obj.p...C566C017E9

The site is wonderful and probably should have a thread of its own, but it is one that I keep forgetting to post about.

Shane
Re: Bronze on early medieval swords
Chad Arnow wrote:
Usually brass (or an equivalent)? I've not heard that before. Most say that bronze was more common and more useable than brass. Any pictures of these brass-hilted swords?

I don't believe real bronze was much used in the medieval period. Nearly all copper based alloys contained at least some amount of zinc by then, making them latten rather then bronze. The one I posted I suspect is latten, as the color looks a bit too yellow to be bronze. Bronze always has a bit reddish hue regardless of tin content, whereas zinc gives a more yellow yellow/green-ish hue. Mind that I'm not talking about modern brass, which often (though not always) contains very high amounts of zinc, and look totally different from the medieval latten, with much lower amounts of zinc and often also tin and lead.
There's a Viking sword dated near that era with a bronze hilt (overlaid with other stuff). There's also a Magyar or Slavic horseman's sword from just prior to your era with bronze fittings.

I don't think I've run across a bronze brazil nut yet, though. There are some swords I've seen where the hilt doesn't look like iron or steel, but the author/cataloguer has neglected to mention what it's made of.

So while there are earlier, and later, examples than your period of bronze being used (some just barely outside your range), I haven't run across examples where they are dated to your target period and described as being of bronze.

Nothing like this yet either: :)

[ Linked Image ]
Bronze on early Medieval Swords
Hi Jeremy,

Here's a picture of a pommel from the Hunt Museum in Limerick Ireland. It's described as being copper alloy-bronze and has a lion and unicorn depicted on it. There is no date given (Cat. No. MG 064).

Richard


 Attachment: 12.67 KB
Hunt Museum Pommel with lion and unicorn MG 064.JPG

There's a beautiful bronze Viking pommel in Peter Finer's 2006 catalogue as well. It's dated to the late 10th century.
Re: Bronze on early medieval swords
Jeremy V. Krause wrote:
Hello everyone,

I have found myself wondering iif early midieval swords (1050-1200) had pommels and or guards made of bronze. Are there examples of bronze brazil nut or tea cozy pommels? The examples I can think of have pommels of iron- and in one case the iron tea cozy was originally covered in gold. If there are historical examples of bronze hilted early medieval swords I think that it would be nice to see someone like Albion make a quality reproduction.

Thanks,
Jeremy


Hey Jeremy,
So in *this* case you prefer me to take chanses with authenticity in my designs, just to please the taste of a contemporary customer?
;)

Joking apart:
There might have been examples of tea cozy pommles in bronze, but I know of no surviving examples. I feel very reluctant to offer this as a design, just because it is such an irregular thing. To me personally it smacks of contemporary wanna-be-a-knight-at-the-renfair aesthetics.
I am sure I will stumble on an original at sometime, and then fall in love. This frequently happens: I tend to come to love those types and features I most detest at first sight or first thought.
Until I see a good original example of a bronze tea cosy pommel, I will be cold to the idea however.

What you do find are disc pommels from the 13th C with beveled edges, often with (religious) emblems or decorations or simply plain and unadorned. They are often hollow and thin.
I have an impression they might have been lead filled: this is just an assumption based on their size and the wall thickness of the casting. Lead can corrode away without leaving much trace to the naked eye.

Guards of bronze areuncommon, but youŽll see them once in a while.
Those examples I can remember would be dated to the 13th C or later.

In "viking" contex you find quite a few bronze hilt components.
With viking, I mean a time period, not neccessarily norse, or scandinavian origin.
With bronze I mean copper alloy.

It seems copper alloy pommel/guard can be found in those types that are less main stream. Perhaps this is a reflection of organization of the craft?
Those who made swords on a regular basis, placed close to the big prodction centres used established forging techniques and worked in iron and steel because of regulation/practise of their guilds.
Perhaps swords manufactured in the fringe areas were made with less orthodox techniques and material combinations?
Something like imported blades with locally cast hilts?
Hi Peter,

I would never reccommend a lossening of the rules to accommodate customer's wishful thinking- I was simpy unaware of any Bronze brazil nut or tez cozy pommels and IF there were examples perhaps this is something to be considered. Thanks very much for your reply. I wonder why we see this archeological space of time between the viking age and the 13th c. in the use of bronze in the pommel.

Thanks,
Jeremy
Hi!

Most of the greek swords and the sabres of the hungarians , pechenegs etc. had bronze guards.

Zoltan
Kipchak sabre, 12. Cent., from the Nat. Museum in Kiev.

Zoltan


 Attachment: 33.1 KB
sl215.jpg


Page 1 of 1

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum




All contents © Copyright 2003-2006 myArmoury.com — All rights reserved
Discussion forums powered by phpBB © The phpBB Group
Switch to the Full-featured Version of the forum