Nat Lamb wrote: |
Upon using google, the book is actually *Achilles* in Vietnam. Author is Jonathan Shay, and after a quick check I found that he gets a mention on the Beserker page on Wikipedia (for whatever that is worth).
If I understand his thesis correctly (psychology is not my field) I think he would argue that PTSD does not necessarily have to be grounded in fear. He seems to put forward that it is an adaption based on a stressful situation or incident which may well be helpful for that situation, but manipulative for others (to use an example from an Australian song, throwing yourself into the dirt when you hear a chopper might help you survive Vietnam, but is a maladaptive behavior if the only chopper in your area is the channel 9 traffic copter) The beserks would seem to fit that description, flipping out into a bloodthirsty hulk-out in response to a perceived threat might be quite useful if you are the Jarl's shock troops, but would be pretty maladaptive behavior for day to day life. |
Interesting. Have to say that beside "fear" Lars R. Møller also states its important for the psyche of the soldier how they are perceived back home and the circumstances on how you leave your unit, especially if you are suddenly parted with them because of injury or being send home.
After war maladaptive behavior is not post traumatic stress disorder per se, only if they persist. Some kind of transition period is needed for all soldiers I would guess (or else everyone would have PTSD!?).
Berserks are described very negatively in the sagas (but they are written by Christians after all).
I'll try here a hypothesis of why they are portrayed in such negative manner (besides being pagan which is bad enough):
When the leaders become Christians they perhaps start more and more to neglect warriors from the Berserker families (being Odin followers)?
Egil Skallagrimsson's grand-dad was a shape-changer called Kveldulf (evening-wolf, so he is a Ulfhedinn a wolf-warrior), who was perceived as turning into a wolf in the evening. So Egil was from a renowned wolf-berserker family.
If they can't find a place in a King's or Jarl's hird any more, what then. Could explain the professional provoker-duelists in Iceland. You could say you create a class of "Ronin". Animal shape-changing families with no outlet for all their rage than going around causing trouble and killing farmers in duels.
No wonder people would start to hate them.....
Once they were elite warriors around famous Kings where Skjalds made poetry about these warband's exploits; now they are "fallen men" despised by all; which just makes them even more angry and eager to kill someone in a duel.
So some becomes so "fallen" that they strike out on the local farm-population perceiving them as enemies (raiding, killing, raping) causing them to became exiled Niddings (outlaws) retreating into the wilderness. Heroes in sagas often kill troublesome berserkers.
Once they were used to go into any farm and be treated like heroes (real warriors doesn't work, they are supposed to be feed by a hero-worshipping population, or Kings with feasts in halls).
I seem to remember (correct me if I'm wrong) Egil Skallagrimson being a guest at a farm (they actually do take him in), but as the farmer doesn't seem REALLY happy to have him Egil Skallagrimson cuts off his nose (he states he is merciful, because his wife will need him on the farm; otherwise he would have killed him or cut of his arms; can't remember the specifics). You are supposed to hero-worship them (in their world-view). Odin in the mythology also ran around in disguise killing people that didn't meet the standards of guest friendship; and Egil is an Odin warrior.
So not so much real combat related PTSD for berserkers, more like wounded pride of no longer being wanted, worshiped and admired; but being obsolete, hated and despised (and having the wrong religion as well). They were full of rage to start with, now all that rage will make most of them slide towards being fully animals (what socially a Nidding is -> a non-human anyone can kill without retribution).
Some berserkers started killing already as children - it was what they did: Raging. It significant that these traits are explained to run in bloodlines; not being caused of combat at all. You are a berserker, since you dad was a berserker.
To them their behavior was heroic and manly - not with Christianity. It doesn't help that Iceland doesn't have any enemy borders you can cross to attack someone and come back being a hero with spoils. If nobody will hire you - then you can't escape Iceland either.
A berserker having PTSD would be one that suddenly couldn't find pleasure in killing anymore or freezing in combat when he should feel joy - that would be traumatic for him. Egil's never have problems like those. When he is old, blind and incontinent he is still killing (the two thralls that helped him bury his treasure - and Egil made sure the secret of the hiding place stayed secret).
Egil Skallagrimsson's dad (Skalla-Grim) actually tried to kill Egil when he was 12 years old, because he entered into wolfish rage. Egil was only save by a thrall, his nurse; but she and Egil's best friend is killed by his dad. In true viking style revenge; Egil then kills his dad's favourite thrall at dinner. "Peace" is then restored in the Berserker home.
Normal behavior for them in their world-view. Growing up in a Berserker family would make you "different" in the eyes of others, but I don't think you can call it PTSD.